Join two MySQL tables with PHP

Question

For example, I have created two pages and two MySQL tables.

Index.php & citys.php

citys

 ID     City       Country  Population
 --------------------------------------
 1      Amsterdam     NL     1500000
 2      Rotterdam     NL     900000
 3      Dusseldorf    DE     1800000

comments

ID   City        Name   Comment
---------------------------------
 1   Dusseldorf  Jack   Great city!
 2   Dusseldorf  John   Beautiful
 3   Rotterdam   Emy    Love it

At the moment I only use the table citys like this:

index.php linking to citys.php with:

<a href='citys.php?cmd=menu&id=";echo $row['id'];echo "'>

And citys.php use this code to show the data from MySQL:

<?php
    include "connect.php";
    if(!isset($cmd))
    {
        if($_GET["cmd"]=="menu" || $_POST["cmd"]=="menu")
        {
            if (!isset($_POST["submit"]))
            {
                $id = $_GET["id"];
                $sql = "SELECT * FROM citys WHERE id=$id";
                $result = mysql_query($sql);
                $row = mysql_fetch_array($result);
?>

<?php echo $row["City"] ?>
<br><br>

<?php echo $row["Country"] ?>
<br><br>
<?php echo $row["Population"] ?>

Until here everything is showing up and working fine.

But I also want to show the comments on page 2. So the query has to be edited to also get the right data from the table comments.

I tried different examples from internet that I have edited myself like:

<?php
    include "connect.php";
    if(!isset($cmd))
    {
        if($_GET["cmd"]=="menu" || $_POST["cmd"]=="menu")
        {
            if (!isset($_POST["submit"]))
            {
                $id = $_GET["id"];
                $sql = "SELECT citys.*, comments.* FROM citys, comments WHERE citys.id=$id AND comments.city=citys.city";
                $result = mysql_query($sql);
                $row = mysql_fetch_array($result);
?>

But nothing works.

How can I fix this?

---

The query from VIPIN JAIN's answer works, but there is one problem left:

Query:

$sql = "SELECT * FROM citys LEFT JOIN comments ON comments.city=citys.city WHERE citys.id=$id";

If the table 'comments' has three rows, this code shows only the last two but not the first:

<?php
    while($row = mysql_fetch_array($result)) {
        echo "<br><br>";
        echo $row['name'];
        echo "<br>";
        echo $row['comment'];
    }
?>

And if I try this it only shows the first row.

<?php echo $row["name"] ?>
<br>
<?php echo $row["comment"] ?>

I don't know why the first record is left away in the loop.

Answer 1

Use this query

$sql = "SELECT * FROM citys LEFT JOIN comments ON comments.city=citys.city WHERE citys.id=$id";

Use leftjoin for this type of work

Answer 2

select * from citys 
left join comments on comments.city = citys.city 
where citys.id=$id