CODEWITHSUNDEEP
javaoverridingextends
zell
zell

Reputation: 10204

Override a protected method, and try to call it from the super class

My question comes from a project. So let me abstract away a bit unrelated details.

I have a JAVA public class A that has two protected static methods, foo() and bar(). The method foo() calls bar() in its body.

public class A{
  protected static foo(){
     ...
     bar()
     ...
  }
  protected static bar(){print("A.bar()");}

}

Now I also have a class B extending A. In B, I override bar() 

class B extends A{
  @Overrides
  static protected bar(){ print("A.bar() extended");

}

Finally, I call foo() from a class in B

class B extends A{
  ...
  public static main(){foo()} 
}

I cannot understand two points 1. The compiler (Eclipse) asks me to remove @Override annotation. Why? 2. Finally the main() outputs "A.bar()", which means the resolved bar() target is of class A, but I intended to override bar() and use the A's foo() to call the modified bar(). How can I do that?

What are your opinions?

Upvotes: 2

Views: 2100

Answers (2)

Guillaume Polet
Guillaume Polet

Reputation: 47608

  1. You cannot override static methods.
  2. Since every method is static it refers to them statically. You first call A.foo() which in turn calls A.bar(). Since you don't have instances, overriding methods does not work.

You need to remove all the static from your code and use new B().foo() in your main.

Consider reading this tutorial.

Upvotes: 7

Hovercraft Full Of Eels
Hovercraft Full Of Eels

Reputation: 285415

You can't override static methods, only non-static instance methods. You're trying to use inheritance in a static environment, and that won't work. If you truly need inheritance (and often when you think you do, really you don't), then make the methods non-static.

Upvotes: 6

Related Questions