CODEWITHSUNDEEP
regexperl
user105033
user105033

Reputation: 19568

What is the difference between \1 and $1 in a Perl regex?

What is the difference of doing \1 as opposed to $1 if any, or are they interchangeable in all situations.

Example:

s/([a-z]+),afklol/$1,bck/;
#against
s/([a-z]+),afklol/\1,bck/;

They both give the same result but is there any difference?

Upvotes: 12

Views: 7845

Answers (3)

user80168
user80168

Reputation:

Straight from perldoc perlre:

Warning on \1 vs $1

Some people get too used to writing things like:

$pattern =~ s/(\W)/\\\1/g;

This is grandfathered for the RHS of a substitute to avoid shocking the sed addicts, but it’s a dirty habit to get into. That’s because in PerlThink, the righthand side of an "s///" is a double- quoted string. "\1" in the usual double-quoted string means a control-A. The customary Unix meaning of "\1" is kludged in for "s///". However, if you get into the habit of doing that, you get yourself into trouble if you then add an "/e" modifier.

s/(\d+)/ \1 + 1 /eg;        # causes warning under -w

Or if you try to do

s/(\d+)/\1000/;

You can’t disambiguate that by saying "{1}000", whereas you can fix it with "${1}000". The operation of interpolation should not be confused with the operation of matching a backreference.

Certainly they mean two different things on the left side of the "s///".

Upvotes: 17

Michael Carman
Michael Carman

Reputation: 30831

I only use \1 on the rare occasions where I need the match to include a repeat of an earlier part of the pattern. e.g.

/(foo|bar)baz\1/

This would match "foobazfoo" or "barbazbar" but not "foobazbar". You can't use $1 there.

In all other circumstances I use $1 and kin, because there are too many gotchas to using the other notation. See perlre for all the gory details.

Upvotes: 11

Beta
Beta

Reputation: 99094

They give the same result, but $1 retains its value while \1 does not. Try this:

s/([a-z]+),afklol/$1,bck/;
print "\$1 is $1\n";
#against
s/([a-z]+),afklol/\1,bck/;
print "\\1 is \1\n";

Upvotes: 1

Related Questions