CODEWITHSUNDEEP
.netf#
Gene Belitski
Gene Belitski

Reputation: 10350

Inconsistent processing of generic ParamArray argument in F#

Being spotted in context of this question this seemingly inconsistent behavior can be reproduced as following both in F#2.0 and F#3.0 RC:

type Heterogeneous =
    static member Echo([<ParamArray>] args: Object[]) = args

type Generic =  
    static member Echo<'T>([<ParamArray>] args: 'T[]) = args

Usage:                                                              Returns:

Heterogeneous.Echo 0              // [|0|]                OK
Generic.Echo 0                    // [|0|]                OK
Heterogeneous.Echo (0,1)          // [|0; 1|]             OK
Generic.Echo (0,1)                // [|0; 1|]             OK
Heterogeneous.Echo [|0|]          // [|[|0|]|]            OK?
Generic.Echo [|0|]                // [|0|]                OOPS!!
Heterogeneous.Echo ([|0|],[|1|])) // [|[|0|]; [|1|]|]     OK
Generic.Echo ([|0|],[|1|]))       // [|[|0|]; [|1|]|]     OK

Can anyone explain if the observed behavior is a bug, or feature?

UPDATE: This related answer communicates a confirmation from F# development team that as of now a bug has place in processing of generic type arguments with ParamArray attribute.

Upvotes: 4

Views: 365

Answers (1)

Tomas Petricek
Tomas Petricek

Reputation: 243096

The case is slightly confusing because when you use an array as an actual argument to a parameter marked with ParamArray, the language tries to interpret it as if you were passing array to a normal array-typed parameter (so it ignores the ParamArray attribute if possible).

In your example, this is possible in the second case:

Generic.Echo [|0|]

The compiler infers that 'T is int and so you're passing int[] to a parameter of type int[] and so the compiler ignores ParamArray attribute and the method simply gets an array containing 0.

In the other case, this is not possible:

Heterogeneous.Echo [|0|]

The method expects a parameter of type obj[] and the type of the argument is int[], so the two types cannot be unified (the key is that the compiler does not automatically convert int[] to obj[]). Since this is not possible, it considers the ParamArray attribute and tries to convert int[] to obj and pass it as a member of ParamArray - this is a conversion that the compiler can automatically perform and so you get the result you described.

If you called Heterogeneous.Echo with obj[] as an argument, then it would behave similarly to Generic.Echo. For example:

Heterogeneous.Echo [| box 0 |]

If you want to go into details, you can look at section 14.4. of the F# language specification. However, the overload resolution rules are pretty complex and so I don't have an exact reference that explains this behaviour - just an informal explanation above.

Upvotes: 5

Related Questions