CODEWITHSUNDEEP
objective-ctypestype-conversion
the_underscore_key
the_underscore_key

Reputation: 117

A float is supposed to be signed, so why is subtraction causing a wrap-around?

float test=-1;

produces a float with value -1. However,

float test=arc4random()%500-500;

produces enormous values that clearly resulted from a buffer overflow -- the numbers wrapping around. This should not happen with a float; for kicks, I tried to see if Xcode would let me make a "signed float", but it told me "floats cannot be signed or unsigned."

I produced a work-around where I made a signed int, then cast it to a float, but I'd really appreciate knowing how/why this happened.

Upvotes: 3

Views: 166

Answers (2)

Caleb
Caleb

Reputation: 124997

arc4random() returns a u_int32_t according to the man page, so arc4random()%500-500 will be an unsigned integer, and subtracting 500 will give you a very large positive value. Try this instead:

float test = ((float)(arc4random() % 500))-500;

I produced a work-around where I made a signed int, then cast it to a float, but I'd really appreciate knowing how/why this happened.

Look at the entire line one piece at a time. First, you've got:

arc4random()

As I said above, that returns an unsigned int. Let's pretend that it returns the value 12345. Next, you've got the modulus operator, so your expression is something like:

12345 % 500

which is to say 345. Next, you subtract 500:

345 - 500

You'd think that'd give you -155, but no -- we're still working in the realm of unsigned ints here, so you really get 4294967141 (or something like that -- my math may be off). Then, finally, you assign that to a float:

float test = 4294967141;

A float only has 23 bits for the mantissa, so the value that's stored in test will be in the general neighborhood of 4294967141, but with less precision, like 4294970000.

Upvotes: 10

Jon Shier
Jon Shier

Reputation: 12770

floats in Objective-C are exactly the same as they are in C: inherently signed as defined by IEEE-754. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Single_precision_floating-point_format

Upvotes: 0

Related Questions