CODEWITHSUNDEEP
javascriptweb-applicationscanvas
Ben Brophy
Ben Brophy

Reputation: 281

Is it better to have one big canvas or up to 100 small dynamically generated canvases?

I am working on a mobile web dice simulator. The initial prototype is here: http://dicewalla.com

I currently have one large canvas where I draw all the dice. I am planning to re-write the code in way that is more MVC and easier for me to update. I think it would be easier for me to generate a small canvas for each die object than to draw all of the dice on the big canvas and keep updating that big canvas.

My question is if there is a bad performance hit in having the browser create lots of little canvases vs one big one. It's hard to test locally, I was hoping someone here might know what the best practice is.

Upvotes: 12

Views: 2135

Answers (2)

joekarl
joekarl

Reputation: 2118

In terms of performance, like was mentioned earlier, there should be little difference between 1-100 canvas elements if you're not updating the graphics on a regular basis. (ie: static graphics / no animation)

Most of the references around the net regarding multiple canvases tend to deal with cases where you have multiple layers and need to handle drawing on top of other things with transparency.

That being said, what you're doing with dicewalla doesn't look like it will gain anything from having multiple canvases.

Also you can selectively redraw the regions of a single canvas to get better performance if updating the entire canvas is a bottleneck. This gives you the performance benefits of having multiple canvases without having to deal with managing and creating those elements.

Upvotes: 4

Brian Ustas
Brian Ustas

Reputation: 65499

Multiple canvases usually allow for better performance as you're able to selectively re-render.

If you have only one canvas and want to update one die, you'll typically have to redraw the entire canvas. On the other hand, multiple canvases allow you to update only the dice that need to be redrawn. That's an increase in efficiency.

Further, you shouldn't see any noticeable difference in loading 1 canvas versus 100.

Upvotes: 4

Related Questions