CODEWITHSUNDEEP
scala
Howard
Howard

Reputation: 19825

When should I use Scala method & function

e.g.

val f1 = (a:Int) => a+1
def f2 = (a:Int) => a+1

Seems they are quite inter-changeable, are there any specific use case which I should use a particular one?

Upvotes: 3

Views: 157

Answers (1)

dhg
dhg

Reputation: 52701

Typically one would write the def version as:

def f2(a:Int) = a+1

If you write it they way you did, it's actually creating a method f2 that, when called, constructs a new function closure. So in both of your cases, you still have a function. But in the first case, the function gets constructed only once and stored (as f1) for later use. But in the second case, the function gets constructed every time f2 is referenced, which is kind of a waste.

So when to prefer a function over a method? Well, you can work with a function a bit more easily in certain situations. Consider this case:

(1 to 3).map(f1 andThen f1)    // totally fine
(1 to 3).map(f2 andThen f1)    // "missing arguments" error
(1 to 3).map(f2 _ andThen f1)  // fixed by adding "_" after the method name

So f1 is always a function and so you can call a method like andThen on it. The variable f2 represents a method, so it doesn't expect to be used like this; it always expects to be followed by arguments. You can always turn a method into a function by following it with an underscore, but this can look a little ugly if it's not necessary.

Upvotes: 4

Related Questions