Scott Chamberlain
Scott Chamberlain

Reputation: 127563

How do to the opposite of "row_number() over (partition by [Col] order by [Col])"

I am trying to combine duplicate entries in a data table and give them a new number.

Here is a example data set (runnable copy)

declare @tmpTable table
    (ID Varchar(1), 
     First varchar(4), 
     Last varchar(5), 
     Phone varchar(13),
     NonKeyField varchar(4))

insert into @tmpTable select 'A', 'John', 'Smith', '(555)555-1234', 'ASDF'
insert into @tmpTable select 'B', 'John', 'Smith', '(555)555-1234', 'GHJK'
insert into @tmpTable select 'C', 'Jane', 'Smith', '(555)555-1234', 'QWER'
insert into @tmpTable select 'D', 'John', 'Smith', '(555)555-1234', 'RTYU'
insert into @tmpTable select 'E', 'Bill', 'Blake', '(555)555-0000', 'BVNM'
insert into @tmpTable select 'F', 'Bill', 'Blake', '(555)555-0000', '%^&*'
insert into @tmpTable select 'G', 'John', 'Smith', '(555)555-1234', '!#RF'

select row_number() over (partition by First, Last, Phone order by ID) NewIDNum, *  
from @tmpTable order by ID

Right now it gives me the results

NewIDNum             ID   First Last  Phone         NonKeyField
-------------------- ---- ----- ----- ------------- -----------
1                    A    John  Smith (555)555-1234 ASDF
2                    B    John  Smith (555)555-1234 GHJK
1                    C    Jane  Smith (555)555-1234 QWER
3                    D    John  Smith (555)555-1234 RTYU
1                    E    Bill  Blake (555)555-0000 BVNM
2                    F    Bill  Blake (555)555-0000 %^&*
4                    G    John  Smith (555)555-1234 !#RF

However that is the opposite of what I want, the NewIDNum resets its counter ever time it finds a new combination of the key. I want all of the same combination to have the same ID. So if it was behaving the way I wanted I would get the following results

NewIDNum             ID   First Last  Phone         NonKeyField
-------------------- ---- ----- ----- ------------- -----------
1                    A    John  Smith (555)555-1234 ASDF
1                    B    John  Smith (555)555-1234 GHJK
2                    C    Jane  Smith (555)555-1234 QWER
1                    D    John  Smith (555)555-1234 RTYU
3                    E    Bill  Blake (555)555-0000 BVNM
3                    F    Bill  Blake (555)555-0000 %^&*
1                    G    John  Smith (555)555-1234 !#RF

What is the correct way to get the results I want?


I did not include this requirement in the original post: I need the NewIDNum to produce the same numbers on subsequent runs of this query for the existing rows if more rows get added (assuming all new rows will have a higher ID "value" if a order by is done on the ID column)

So if at a latter date the following was done

insert into @tmpTable select 'H', 'John', 'Smith', '(555)555-1234', '4321'
insert into @tmpTable select 'I', 'Jake', 'Jons', '(555)555-1234', '1234'
insert into @tmpTable select 'J', 'John', 'Smith', '(555)555-1234', '2345'

running the correct query again would give

NewIDNum             ID   First Last  Phone         NonKeyField
-------------------- ---- ----- ----- ------------- -----------
1                    A    John  Smith (555)555-1234 ASDF
1                    B    John  Smith (555)555-1234 GHJK
2                    C    Jane  Smith (555)555-1234 QWER
1                    D    John  Smith (555)555-1234 RTYU
3                    E    Bill  Blake (555)555-0000 BVNM
3                    F    Bill  Blake (555)555-0000 %^&*
1                    G    John  Smith (555)555-1234 !#RF
1                    H    John  Smith (555)555-1234 4321
4                    I    Jake  Jons  (555)555-1234 1234
1                    J    John  Smith (555)555-1234 2345

Upvotes: 9

Views: 5659

Answers (4)

Scott Chamberlain
Scott Chamberlain

Reputation: 127563

Thanks to Andomar's answer as a jumping off point I solved it myself

select sub1.rn, tt.*
from @tmpTable tt
inner join (
    select row_number() over (order by min(ID)) as rn, first, last, phone
    from @tmpTable
    group by first, last, phone
    ) as sub1 on tt.first = sub1.first and tt.last = sub1.last and tt.phone = sub1.phone

this produces

rn                   ID   First Last  Phone         NonKeyField
-------------------- ---- ----- ----- ------------- -----------
1                    A    John  Smith (555)555-1234 ASDF
1                    B    John  Smith (555)555-1234 GHJK
1                    D    John  Smith (555)555-1234 RTYU
1                    G    John  Smith (555)555-1234 !#RF
1                    H    John  Smith (555)555-1234 4321
1                    J    John  Smith (555)555-1234 2345
2                    C    Jane  Smith (555)555-1234 QWER
3                    E    Bill  Blake (555)555-0000 BVNM
3                    F    Bill  Blake (555)555-0000 %^&*
4                    I    Jake  Jons  (555)555-1234 1234

Looking at the SQL Execution plan, Adnomar's answer will run quicker for larger data sets than mine. (53% execution time VS 47% execution time when run next to each other and "Include actual execution plan" checked.

Upvotes: 0

Andomar
Andomar

Reputation: 238096

You could use dense_rank():

dense_rank() over (order by First, Last, Phone) as NewIDNum

In response to your comment, you could sort on the minimum of the old Id column per group of rows with the same (First, Last, Phone) combination:

select  *
from    (
        select  dense_rank() over (order by min_id) as new_id
        ,       *
        from    (
                select  min(id) over (
                            partition by First, Last, Phone) as min_id
                ,       *
                from    @tmpTable 
                ) as sub1
        ) as sub3
order by
        new_id

Upvotes: 8

etliens
etliens

Reputation: 1342

Building on @Andomar's original answer -- this will work on your updated requirements (though this won't likely scale nicely)

select
    DENSE_RANK() over (ORDER BY IdRank, First, Last, Phone) AS NewIDNum,
    ID,
    First,
    Last,
    Phone,
    NonKeyField
from
(
    select
        MIN(ID) OVER (PARTITION BY First, Last, Phone) as IdRank,
        *
    from
        @tmpTable
) as x
order by
    ID;

Upvotes: 1

iruvar
iruvar

Reputation: 23364

This should work

select dense_rank() over (order by First, Last, Phone) NewIDNum, *  
from @tmpTable order by ID

Upvotes: -1

Related Questions