CODEWITHSUNDEEP
pythonfilepath
user1905410
user1905410

Reputation: 1231

Why use os.path.join over string concatenation?

I'm not able to see the bigger picture here I think; but basically I have no idea why you would use os.path.join instead of just normal string concatenation?

I have mainly used VBScript so I don't understand the point of this function.

Upvotes: 120

Views: 33057

Answers (3)

user1902824
user1902824

Reputation:

Portable

Write filepath manipulations once and it works across many different platforms, for free. The delimiting character is abstracted away, making your job easier.

Smart

You no longer need to worry if that directory path had a trailing slash or not. os.path.join will add it if it needs to.

Clear

Using os.path.join makes it obvious to other people reading your code that you are working with filepaths. People can quickly scan through the code and discover it's a filepath intrinsically. If you decide to construct it yourself, you will likely detract the reader from finding actual problems with your code: "Hmm, some string concats, a substitution. Is this a filepath or what? Gah! Why didn't he use os.path.join?" :)

Upvotes: 122

jassinm
jassinm

Reputation: 7491

Will work on Windows with '\' and Unix (including Mac OS X) with '/'.

for posixpath here's the straightforward code

In [22]: os.path.join??
Type:       function
String Form:<function join at 0x107c28ed8>
File:       /usr/local/Cellar/python/2.7.3/Frameworks/Python.framework/Versions/2.7/lib/python2.7/posixpath.py
Definition: os.path.join(a, *p)
Source:
def join(a, *p):
    """Join two or more pathname components, inserting '/' as needed.
    If any component is an absolute path, all previous path components
    will be discarded."""
    path = a
    for b in p:
        if b.startswith('/'):
            path = b
        elif path == '' or path.endswith('/'):
            path +=  b
        else:
            path += '/' + b
    return path

don't have windows but the same should be there with '\'

Upvotes: 5

bkaiser
bkaiser

Reputation: 657

It is OS-independent. If you hardcode your paths as C:\Whatever they will only work on Windows. If you hardcode them with the Unix standard "/" they will only work on Unix. os.path.join detects the operating system it is running under and joins the paths using the correct symbol.

Upvotes: -1

Related Questions