CODEWITHSUNDEEP
javacjava-native-interface
DevSolar
DevSolar

Reputation: 70243

Passing large C structure through JNI efficiently

I have a large C structure (about 40 members, int and char[]) which I have to pass through JNI to the Java side for further processing. This happens repeatedly. (I already put the GetMethodID() etc. into an init() function on the C side so I only have to call them once.)

What would be an efficient way to do this?

I can think of:

  1. Instantiating a Java class with the appropriate members through GetMethodID( ..., "<init>", ... ) and passing all members of the C structure through the constructor;
  2. Assigning a Java struct with the appropriate members, and initializing the (public) members through SetXYZField();
  3. ...

Did I overlook something? (This is my first "close combat" with JNI.) Is there really no efficient way to "sync" a C structure and a Java structure?

What is the more efficient passing method, 1. or 2.? In case of 1., should I pass constructor parameters through CallXYZMethod() (parameter list) or CallXYZMethodA() (argument array)?

Thanks for your input.

Edit: Reworded slightly; 2. doesn't need to be a class of course, and I don't strictly need a struct on the Java side if there is some other solution to handle the C data on the Java side.

Edit 2: I do this in C++, but the struct itself stems from a C-linkage callback function, i.e. nothing C++-specific to the problem. Rephrased to read "C" instead of "C++".

Upvotes: 3

Views: 4429

Answers (2)

MHarris
MHarris

Reputation: 1821

For pure efficiency, it's best to minimize calls that go through JNI, so your best bet is sending all the data in either through option 1 and creating a new object.

You could also have a "recieveUpdate( ... 40 params ...)" method on the Java side if you wanted to avoid allocating a new object per update, though it's cringeworthy design.

Upvotes: 1

Henry B
Henry B

Reputation: 8047

I'm sorry I don't have time to write an indepth answer or look in to this further but a while ago I had to do quite a lot of work with JNI and I found that using SWiG help hugely. I'm not sure of its efficiency but I imagine it generates pretty efficient code.

Anyway, check it out SWiG there's a bit on Passing structures by value and main Structures.

Good luck.

Upvotes: 1

Related Questions