CODEWITHSUNDEEP
sqlindexingouter-join
Starfield
Starfield

Reputation: 119

Index usage with OUTER JOIN that contains IN statement

SELECT a.*, b.* 
FROM a
    LEFT OUTER JOIN b 
        ON b.user IN (:userlist) 
        AND b.key = a.fk_to_b
WHERE 
a.user IN (:userlist) 
OR b.user IN (:userlist)

The database only uses the index when the :userlist parameter contains a single value. When :users contains multiple values (which internally expands to multiple OR statements?) the index is not used and a table scan (of b) is performed.

Why isn't the database using the index when multiple :userlist values are supplied?

Does anyone know of a more optimal version of this query?

Upvotes: 2

Views: 349

Answers (3)

user78706
user78706

Reputation:

IN (:userlist) expands to multiple OR statements.
The query optimizer disregards OR lines/clauses.
Here's what to do if the DB is Oracle: 

CREATE TABLE userListTable  
(  
   sessionId NUMBER(9),  
   user      NUMBER(9)  
);  

CREATE INDEX userListTableMulti1 ON userListTable(sessionId,user);

... 

CREATE OR REPLACE FUNCTION fn_getUserList(parmUserList VARCHAR2)  
   RETURN NUMBER DETERMINISTIC  
   varUser      NUMBER(9);  
   varSessionId NUMBER(9);  
BEGIN  
   varSessionId := sys_context('USERENV','SESSIONID');  

   -- You have to work on a VARCHAR2TOLIST() function  
   FOR varUser IN VARCHAR2TOLIST(parmUserList) LOOP  
      INSERT INTO userListTable(sessionId,user)  
      VALUES(varSessionId, varUser)  
   END LOOP;  

   INSERT INTO resultsTable  
      SELECT  
         varSessionId as sessionId ,  
         a.*                       ,  
         b.*  
      FROM  
         (SELECT a.*  
          FROM a  
             INNER JOIN userListTable  
             ON a.user = userListTable.user AND  
                userListTable.sessionId = varSessionId) a  
         LEFT OUTER JOIN (SELECT b.*  
                          FROM b  
                             INNER JOIN userListTable  
                             ON b.user = userListTable.user AND  
                                userListTable.sessionId = varSessionId) b  
         ON b.key = a.fk_to_b;  

   RETURN varSessionId;  
END;  
/

... 

// C Client side  
int   varSessionId;  
char* parmUserList;  
char* sqlStr;  

...  

sqlStr = (char*)malloc( strlen(parmUserList) + 17 ) ;  
sprintf(sqlStr,"fn_getUserList(%s)", parmUserList);  

// EXEC_SQL_FUNC_C_MACRO  
// EXEC_SQL_RETURN_QUERY_RESULTS_C_MACRO  
// EXEC_SQL_C_MACRO  
// are all based on the database API C libraries  

// Run the function for this session  
varSessionId = EXEC_SQL_FUNC_C_MACRO(sqlStr);  
free(sqlStr);  

// Get the results  
sqlStr = (char*)malloc(128);  
sprintf(  
   sqlStr,  
   "SELECT * "  
   "FROM resultsTable "  
   "WHERE sessionId=%s",  
   varSessionId);  
EXEC_SQL_RETURN_QUERY_RESULTS_C_MACRO(sqlStr);  
free(sqlStr);  

...  

// Clean up the resultsTable for this session  
sqlStr = (char*)malloc(128);  
sprintf(  
   sqlStr,  
   "DELETE "  
   "FROM resultsTable "  
   "WHERE sessionId=%s",  
   varSessionId);  
EXEC_SQL_C_MACRO(sqlStr);  
free(sqlStr);  

// Clean up the userListTable for this session  
sqlStr = (char*)malloc(128);  
sprintf(  
   sqlStr,  
   "DELETE "  
   "FROM userListTable "  
   "WHERE sessionId=%s",  
   varSessionId);  
EXEC_SQL_C_MACRO(sqlStr);  
free(sqlStr);

Upvotes: 0

Matthew Farwell
Matthew Farwell

Reputation: 61705

The quick answer is: It depends.

If you specify multiple values in :userlist, then the database server may choose to optimise the query in a different way, it may choose a full table scan for instance.

Most of the time, the best option is to see how the query is optimised, by doing

  1. EXPLAIN PLAN in Oracle
  2. Show Execution Plan in SQL server.

To help you more, we really need to know which database you're using.

Upvotes: 0

Quassnoi
Quassnoi

Reputation: 425381

This query will work in all major systems and probably will be more efficient:

SELECT  a.*, NULL
FROM    a
WHERE   a.user IN (:userlist)
        AND a.fk_to_b NOT IN
        (
        SELECT  key
        FROM    b
        )
UNION ALL
SELECT  a.*, b.id
FROM    a
JOIN    b
ON      b.key = a.fk_to_b
WHERE   b.user IN (:userlist)

Could you please tell which RDBMS do you use?

Upvotes: 1

Related Questions