CODEWITHSUNDEEP
sqldelphisql-injection
Mattl
Mattl

Reputation: 1618

Protecting strings within a Delphi application

We have a Delphi 2006 application that drives a MS SQL Server database.

We have found a vulnerability where it is possible to load the executable into a hex editor and modify the SQL.

Our long term plan is to move this SQL to CLR stored procedures but this is some way off since many of our clients still use SQL 2000.

We've thought about obfuscating the strings, does anyone have a recommendation for a tool for doing this?

Is there a better solution, maybe code signing?

Upvotes: 0

Views: 1728

Answers (10)

ThinkJet
ThinkJet

Reputation: 6735

  1. Move DB interface to stored procedures. Normal regular stored procedures without any CLR. It's not a big deal if you already have queries to put inside.

  2. If you don't want to learn T-SQL for some reasons, simple move all you query string to database and store in application single query, which purpose is reading SQL code with given query ID from database only.

All tricks with encoding produces a lot of troubles, but don't give any real security because must use reversable encrypting (dictated by the nature of the problem) and all keys for decoding placed in application executable too.

Upvotes: 1

user160694
user160694

Reputation:

A solution that would require a deep restructuring of the application would be to use a multi-tier approach - most the of the SQL code would be in the application server module, that being on a server should be more protected than a client side exe.

Upvotes: 2

Warren P
Warren P

Reputation: 68872

This is not a vulnerability. If your machines are vulnerable to having people locally modify EXEs, that is your vulnerability.

All EXEs can be hacked, if someone has local admin account access, your game is over long before they get near your resource strings.

Upvotes: 6

Leonardo Herrera
Leonardo Herrera

Reputation: 8406

Sorry for being blunt, but if you are thinking of applying "security" measures in your executable you are doomed. No scrambling schema will retain an average hacker.

You also haven't explained how is your app designed. Is the database hosted by you, or resides in your client's premises? If the latter, then just forget about security and start hiring a lawyer to get a good confidentiality contract so your clients behave. If the former, then using stored procedures is the easiest way.

Upvotes: 9

Wodzu
Wodzu

Reputation: 6979

Can't you encrypt all your queries and put them to the resource file? During runtime, firstly you would have to:

  1. Load your query string from resource.
  2. Decrypt it.

Then you just run your query as before.

That should not be a big problem. Of course if you are not storing your queries in some resource / folder than you need to refactor your application a bit. But you should store them anyway in some organized manner. So you will be hitting a two birds with one stone here ;-)

For encryption of the strings you could use a free library called DCPCrypt.

Upvotes: 1

Tobias Langner
Tobias Langner

Reputation: 10808

First - do an analysis of your threat. Who is using your vulnerability, why is this a problem. Then act accordingly.

If your application is win32 and your threat are some kids witch are just having fun, a free exe packer (e.g. upx) might be the solution. On .NET applications signing might be what you want.

If you need more than that, it's going to be expensive and it's going to be more difficult to develop your application. Perhaps you even need to restructure it. Commercial protection schemes are available (perhaps with dongle?) - even protection schemes where you store your strings on some external hardware. If the hardware is not present, no SQL-Strings. But, as I said, that's more expensive.

Upvotes: 1

mj2008
mj2008

Reputation: 6747

It will never be possible to protect completely, but you can make "casual attack" harder. The simple system that I use is a "ROT47" type system which is like ROT13 but wider ranging. The code then gets to look like the following:

frmLogin.Caption := xIniFile.ReadString(Rot47('$JDE6>' {CODEME'System'}),

The key here is that I have a comment which includes the string so both I can see it, but more importantly so can the utility that I run in my FinalBuilder build script. This allows me to ensure that strings are up-to-date at all times in release code. The utility looks for {CODEME in the lines, and if found knows the format of the data to output appropriately.

Upvotes: 3

Marco van de Voort
Marco van de Voort

Reputation: 26358

There are "protection" suites that encrypt and/or validate your exe before running. searching for "encrypt exe" or "validate exe" or so will probably help. Usually they are payware, but sub $100.

The principle is the same as an exe packer (and has some of its downsides, like cheaper antivirus heuristics sometimes reacting on them, a slightly elevated memory load), just more focussed on security. A problem is also that for most exe packers, depackers exist.

I use dinkeydongle's wares, but that is a kind that also ties into an hardware dongle, so that might be a bridge to far for you.

Upvotes: 0

gbn
gbn

Reputation: 432210

If embedded SQL is being hacked, then it implies that your database is quite open and anyone with MSQRY32.EXE (that is, MS Office) can get your data.

If you are a vendor, then you can't rely on CLR being enabled at your clients. So, why not use non-CLR stored procedures and correct permissioning in the database that is version independent?

Upvotes: 7

Sarfraz
Sarfraz

Reputation: 382686

I think you should use a exe packer which makes it hard for anyone to modify the stuff using hex editor.

Upvotes: 1

Related Questions