How to determine the true data type of an NSNumber?

Question

Consider this code:

NSNumber* interchangeId = dict[@"interchangeMarkerLogId"];
long long llValue = [interchangeId longLongValue];
double dValue = [interchangeId doubleValue];
NSNumber* doubleId = [NSNumber numberWithDouble:dValue];
long long llDouble = [doubleId longLongValue];
if (llValue > 1000000) {
    NSLog(@"Have Marker iD = %@,  interchangeId = %@, long long value = %lld, doubleNumber = %@, doubleAsLL = %lld, CType = %s, longlong = %s", self.iD, interchangeId, llValue, doubleId, llDouble, [interchangeId objCType], @encode(long long));
}

The results:

Have Marker iD = (null), interchangeId = 635168520811866143, long long value = 635168520811866143, doubleNumber = 6.351685208118661e+17, doubleAsLL = 635168520811866112, CType = d, longlong = q

dict is coming from NSJSONSerialization, and the original JSON source data is "interchangeId":635168520811866143. It appears that all 18 digits of the value have been captured in the NSNumber, so it could not possibly have been accumulated by NSJSONSerialization as a double (which is limited to 16 decimal digits). Yet, objCType is reporting that it's a double.

We find this in the documentation for NSNumber: "The returned type does not necessarily match the method the receiver was created with." So apparently this is a "feechure" (i.e., documented bug).

So how can I determine that this value originated as an integer and not a floating point value, so I can extract it correctly, with all the available precision? (Keep in mind that I have some other values that are legitimately floating-point, and I need to extract those accurately as well.)

I've come up with two solutions so far:

The first, which does not make use of knowledge of NSDecimalNumber --

NSString* numberString = [obj stringValue];
BOOL fixed = YES;
for (int i = 0; i < numberString.length; i++) {
    unichar theChar = [numberString characterAtIndex:i];
    if (theChar != '-' && (theChar < '0' || theChar > '9')) {
        fixed = NO;
        break;
    }
}

The second, which assumes that we only need worry about NSDecimalNumber objects, and can trust the CType results from regular NSNumbers --

if ([obj isKindOfClass:[NSDecimalNumber class]]) {
    // Need to determine if integer or floating-point.  NSDecimalNumber is a subclass of NSNumber, but it always reports it's type as double.
    NSDecimal decimalStruct = [obj decimalValue];
    // The decimal value is usually "compact", so may have a positive exponent even if integer (due to trailing zeros).  "Length" is expressed in terms of 4-digit halfwords.
    if (decimalStruct._exponent >= 0 && decimalStruct._exponent + 4 * decimalStruct._length < 20) {
        sqlite3_bind_int64(pStmt, idx, [obj longLongValue]);            
    }
    else {
        sqlite3_bind_double(pStmt, idx, [obj doubleValue]);           
    }
}
else ... handle regular NSNumber by testing CType.

The second should be more efficient, especially since it does not need to create a new object, but is slightly worrisome in that it depends on "undocumented behavior/interface" of NSDecimal -- the meanings of the fields are not documented anywhere (that I can find) and are said to be "private".

Both appear to work.

Though on thinking about it a bit -- The second approach has some "boundary" problems, since one can't readily adjust the limits to assure that the maximum possible 64-bit binary int will "pass" without risking loss of a slightly larger number.

Rather unbelievably, this scheme fails in some cases:

BOOL fixed = NO;
long long llValue = [obj longLongValue];
NSNumber* testNumber = [[NSNumber alloc] initWithLongLong:llValue];
if ([testNumber isEqualToNumber:obj]) {
    fixed = YES;
}

I didn't save the value, but there is one for which the NSNumber will essentially be unequal to itself -- the values both display the same but do not register as equal (and it is certain that the value originated as an integer).

This appears to work, so far:

BOOL fixed = NO;
if ([obj isKindOfClass:[NSNumber class]]) {
     long long llValue = [obj longLongValue];
     NSNumber* testNumber = [[[obj class] alloc] initWithLongLong:llValue];
     if ([testNumber isEqualToNumber:obj]) {
         fixed = YES;
     }
 }

Apparently isEqualToNumber does not work reliably between an NSNumber and an NSDecimalNumber.

(But the bounty is still open, for the best suggestion or improvement.)

Answer 1

if ([data isKindOfClass: [NSNumber class]]) {
           NSNumber *num = (NSNumber *)data;
           if (strcmp([data objCType], @encode(float)) == 0) {
               return [NSString stringWithFormat:@"%0.1f} ",num.floatValue];
           } else if (strcmp([data objCType], @encode(double)) == 0) {
               return [NSString stringWithFormat:@"%0.1f} ",num.doubleValue];
           } else if (strcmp([data objCType], @encode(int)) == 0) {
               return [NSString stringWithFormat:@"%d} ",num.intValue];
           } else if (strcmp([data objCType], @encode(BOOL)) == 0) {
               return  num.boolValue ? @"Yes} " : @"No} ";
           } else if (strcmp([data objCType], @encode(long)) == 0) {
               return [NSString stringWithFormat:@"%ld} ",num.longValue];
           }
       } 

Answer 2

NSJSONSerializer returns:

an integer NSNumber for integers up to 18 digits

an NSDecimalNumber for integers with 19 or more digits

a double NSNumber for numbers with decimals or exponent

a BOOL NSNumber for true and false.

Compare directly with the global variables kCFBooleanFalse and kCFBooleanTrue (spelling might be wrong) to find booleans. Check isKindOfClass:[NSDecimalNumber class] for decimal numbers; these are actually integers. Test

strcmp (number.objCType, @encode (double)) == 0

for double NSNumbers. This will unfortunately match NSDecimalNumber as well, so test that first.

Answer 3

As documented in NSDecimalNumber.h, NSDecimalNumber always returns "d" for it's return type. This is expected behavior.

- (const char *)objCType NS_RETURNS_INNER_POINTER;
    // return 'd' for double

And also in the Developer Docs:

Returns a C string containing the Objective-C type of the data contained in the
receiver, which for an NSDecimalNumber object is always “d” (for double).

CFNumberGetValue is documented to return false if the conversion was lossy. In the event of a lossy conversion, or when you encounter an NSDecimalNumber, you will want to fall back to using the stringValue and then use sqlite3_bind_text to bind it (and use sqlite's column affinity).

Something like this:

NSNumber *number = ...
BOOL ok = NO;

if (![number isKindOfClass:[NSDecimalNumber class]]) {
    CFNumberType numberType = CFNumberGetType(number);

    if (numberType == kCFNumberFloat32Type ||
        numberType == kCFNumberFloat64Type ||
        numberType == kCFNumberCGFloatType)
    {
        double value;
        ok = CFNumberGetValue(number, kCFNumberFloat64Type, &value);

        if (ok) {
            ok = (sqlite3_bind_double(pStmt, idx, value) == SQLITE_OK);
        }

    } else {
        SInt64 value;
        ok = CFNumberGetValue(number, kCFNumberSInt64Type, &value);

        if (ok) {
            ok = (sqlite3_bind_int64(pStmt, idx, value) == SQLITE_OK);
        }
    }
}

// We had an NSDecimalNumber, or the conversion via CFNumberGetValue() was lossy.
if (!ok) {
    NSString *stringValue = [number stringValue];
    ok = (sqlite3_bind_text(pStmt, idx, [stringValue UTF8String], -1, SQLITE_TRANSIENT) == SQLITE_OK);
}

Answer 4

Ok--It's not 100% ideal, but you add a little bit of code to SBJSON to achieve what you want.

1. First, add NSNumber+SBJson to the SBJSON project:

NSNumber+SBJson.h

@interface NSNumber (SBJson)
@property ( nonatomic ) BOOL isDouble ;
@end

NSNumber+SBJson.m

#import "NSNumber+SBJSON.h"
#import <objc/runtime.h>

@implementation NSNumber (SBJson)

static const char * kIsDoubleKey = "kIsDoubleKey" ;

-(void)setIsDouble:(BOOL)b
{
    objc_setAssociatedObject( self, kIsDoubleKey, [ NSNumber numberWithBool:b ], OBJC_ASSOCIATION_RETAIN_NONATOMIC ) ;
}

-(BOOL)isDouble
{
    return [ objc_getAssociatedObject( self, kIsDoubleKey ) boolValue ] ;
}

@end

2. Now, find the line in SBJson4StreamParser.m where sbjson4_token_real is handled. Change the code as follows:

case sbjson4_token_real: {
    NSNumber * number = @(strtod(token, NULL)) ;
    number.isDouble = YES ;
    [_delegate parserFoundNumber:number ];
    [_state parser:self shouldTransitionTo:tok];
    break;
}

note the bold line... this will mark a number created from a JSON real as a double.

3. Finally, you can check the isDouble property on your number objects decoded via SBJSON

HTH

edit:

(Of course you could generalize this and replace the added isDouble with a generic type indicator if you like)

Answer 5

Simple answer: You can't.

In order to do what you're asking, you'll need to keep track of the exact type on your own. NSNumber is more of a "dumb" wrapper in that it helps you use standard numbers in a more objective way (as Obj-C objects). Using solely NSNumber, -objCType is your only way. If you want another way, you'd have to do it on your own.

Here are some other discussions that may be of help:

get type of NSNumber

What's the largest value an NSNumber can store?

Why is longLongValue returning the incorrect value

NSJSONSerialization unboxes NSNumber?