CODEWITHSUNDEEP
c++volatile
user1508519
user1508519

Reputation:

Why does a const reference to volatile int need a static_cast?

Given the following code:

struct Foo { 
    volatile int i; 
};

const int& bar = foo.i;

I get:

error: invalid initialization of reference of type 'const int&' from expression of type 'volatile int'

Unless I provide a static_cast<volatile int>.

Upvotes: 3

Views: 2349

Answers (2)

Mike Seymour
Mike Seymour

Reputation: 254471

As with const, a volatile object can only be referred to by a volatile reference. Otherwise, the compiler has no way of knowing that accesses to the object via the reference need to be volatile.

volatile const int& bar = foo.i;
^^^^^^^^

Unless I provide a static_cast<volatile int>

It's rarely a good idea to silence a compiler error by adding casts. This doesn't give you a reference to foo.i, but to a separate copy of it.

If you are doing something really strange that requires a non-volatile reference to a volatile object, you'd need const_cast to remove the qualifer:

const int& weird = const_cast<int&>(foo.i);

Upvotes: 3

Tristan Brindle
Tristan Brindle

Reputation: 16824

"Volatility" of types in C++ works in pretty much exactly the same way as "const-ness" -- that is, an object that is volatile cannot be assigned to a non-volatile reference, in just the same way that

const int i = 3;
int& j = i; // won't work

Similarly, only methods marked volatile can be called on a volatile object:

struct S
{
    void do_something() volatile {}
    void do_something_else() {}
};

volatile S s;
s.do_something(); // fine
s.do_something_else(); // won't work

Methods can be overloaded by "volatility", in the same way they can be overloaded by const-ness.

In C++ standardese, these things are known as cv-qualifiers, to emphasise that they work in exactly the same way. (C99 adds a third that works in the same way, restrict, available as an extension in some C++ compilers). You can change cv qualifiers using const_cast<> -- the more powerful static_cast<> isn't required.

EDIT:

Just to make clear, a type can have both const and volatile modifiers at the same time, giving a total of four possibilities:

int i;
const int j;
volatile int k;
const volatile int l;

Upvotes: 7

Related Questions