CODEWITHSUNDEEP
dart
mezoni
mezoni

Reputation: 11210

Why are there special "sealed" classes in Dart, and how can I make those?

There seem to be some special classes in Dart such as num, that cannot be normally inherited by user-defined classes, although there is nothing in the Dart syntax itself which prevents it (such as Java's final or C#'s sealed). num is inherited by the built-in int and double, though.

  1. Why is that? Shouldn't this limitation appear in the language's syntax?
  2. Is there any way I could create such classes myself, that are partially or fully "sealed" against inheritance?

Upvotes: 3

Views: 1046

Answers (1)

mezoni
mezoni

Reputation: 11210

Here is an official answer on similar question from Dart Team that was found on https://code.google.com/p/dart/issues/list.

Gilad Bracha said on this occasion:

You could almost think of int, double, bool, Null and String as final classes in Java (num doesn't fit that mold as it has subtypes). By design, we don't support final classes, to minimize complexity and avoid code where you cannot subclass (much as the submitter wants). Instead of final classes, we chose to have list of types that cannot be extended.

Why: because these are critical for efficiency. Its not a very purist argument, but pragmatically most people would trade the flexibility for a faster system.

++++++++

RE: Comment from me: It's really not a very purist argument because this not helps make language clearer and better in the end.

++++++++

Also this is not out of context words, but this is the official position of Jun 29, 2012.

Maybe today there is another interpretation from the Dart Team, but it will be available only from the official response to the questions raised.

P.S.

Tnanks to ringstaff for the link to this answer.

P.S.

Please leave your comments on this official position if you want make Dart language clearer and better.

In an afterword:

  • This is not a flexibility, this is a crudity of decisions (about language design and the implementation of its environment).

Upvotes: 2

Related Questions