CODEWITHSUNDEEP
c++namespaces
abbasi
abbasi

Reputation: 121

Why using namespace doesn't work in my C++ project?

I after vast effort could (details are in here FLTK version 1.3.2, Visual studio 2012 and the first example of Stroustrup's PPP book) to ran the below code;

#include <Simple_window.h>    
#include <Graph.h>  

//*********************************************

int main()
{
    using namespace Graph_lib; 

    Point tl(100,100);
    Simple_window win(tl,600,400,"Canvas");


    Graph_lib::Polygon poly;
    poly.add(Point(300,200));
    poly.add(Point(350,100));
    poly.add(Point(400,200));
    win.attach(poly);


    win.set_label("Canvas");
    win.wait_for_button();   
}

But for Polygon poly; I should use Graph_lib::, while since I have added the statement using namespace Graph_lib; at the top of the code's body (just below the main function) so there should not be any need to use the Graph_lib:: for Polygon. But in effect without using it I get ambiguous symbol error. and also even I remove that statement (using namespace Graph_lib;) I don't get any error. My question is that why that statement doesn't work for that code and I have to use Graph_lib::?

Upvotes: 1

Views: 2334

Answers (2)

juanchopanza
juanchopanza

Reputation: 227578

Most likely you have something else called Polygon. Namespaces exist so that you can avoid this type of problem.

Here's a simplified example:

namespace Foo
{
  struct Bar {};
}

void Bar() {}

int main()
{
  using namespace Foo; // I really really know what I am doing, seriously!
  Bar b;               // Oh dear.
}

In the output:

error: reference to 'Bar' is ambiguous

This is one good example of the pitfalls of the using namespace X anti-idiom. This really should be avoided, or at the very least limited to the smallest of scopes.

Upvotes: 5

kikobyte
kikobyte

Reputation: 344

Likely, there is another Polygon declared either in global namespace, or in some namespace you're already "using" (like if you have using namespace XXX; in another included header, which is not a good practice, and something like XXX::Polygon is declared).

What I can suggest you as a quick solution (if you really want to use Graph_lib's Polygon without "Graph_lib::", is

using Graph_lib::Polygon;

instead of (or next to) 

using namespace Graph_lib;

Upvotes: 0

Related Questions