Reputation: 15387
I need to make spherical billboards (i.e., setting depth), but taking into account perspective projection--ideally including off-center frusta.
I wasn't able to find any references to anyone succeeding at this--although there are plenty of explanations as to why standard billboards don't have perspective distortions. Unfortunately, for my application, the lack isn't a cosmetic defect; it's actually important to the algorithm.
I did a bit of investigation on my own:
The math gets pretty messy rather quickly. The obvious approaches don't work: for example, you can't orient the billboard perpendicular to a viewing ray because tangential rays wouldn't intersect the billboard at right angles.
Probably the most promising approach I found was to render the billboard parallel to the near clipping plane, stretching it with a vertex shader into an ellipse. This only handles perturbations along one axis (so e.g. it won't handle spheres rendered in a corner of the view), but the main obstacle is calculating depth correctly; you can't compute it as you would for an undistorted sphere because the "sphere" is occluding itself.
Point of fact, I didn't find a good solution, and I couldn't find anyone who has. Anyone have an idea?
Upvotes: 1
Views: 935
Reputation: 15387
While browsing around not even remotely working on this problem, I stumbled on http://iquilezles.org/www/articles/sphereproj/sphereproj.htm, which is pretty close. The linked tutorial shows how to compute a bounding ellipse for a rasterized sphere; getting the depth (at worst, using a raycast) should be fairly easy to derive.
Upvotes: 2