CODEWITHSUNDEEP
coptional-parameters
philcolbourn
philcolbourn

Reputation: 4122

Can you still do variable arguments in C the old way?

Purely for interest, I am re-learning C after ... I don't know ... 15 - 20 years.

I seem to recall that variable arguments were implemented as simple macros.

Edit: To clarify my question, I know they had the same name as va_list etc. but can you remember the actual macro definition?

Upvotes: 1

Views: 378

Answers (5)

AProgrammer
AProgrammer

Reputation: 52314

Even before the standardisation, methods of doing variable arguments were common. The C89 standard gave a ... standardized interface based on the existing practices. Remainders of those practice still exist at place, for instance <varargs.h> was still present in Unix98: http://www.opengroup.org/onlinepubs/007908799/xsh/varargs.h.html (but is no more present in current version)

The implementation of the macros was always very much system dependent (there are stacks growing in both directions, there are even systems using a linked list as stack, position of various things in the stack frame depend on the processor and common convention, on some processors -- says Sparc -- one need first to save the registers, alignment requirements may cause problems,...)

If you want to know what would a simple implementation looks like, here is one, depending on assumptions probably false (they don't try to get any alignment right) and also certainly failing some corner cases even when the assumptions hold:

typedef void* va_list;
#define va_start(va, arg) va = (void*)((&arg)+1)
#define va_arg(va, type)  (va = (void*)(((type*)va) + 1), *((type*)va -1)
#define va_end(va)

Upvotes: 1

anon
anon

Reputation:

Variadic functions are indeed commonly implemented using macros. These are standardised - see this wikipedia article on the subject. The actual macro definitions are dependent on the processor architecture, as they have to play non-portable games with the call stack.

Upvotes: 1

user50049
user50049

Reputation:

Its hard to say if your implementation of them from way back when would still work, however they are pretty much the same as others have pointed out, they just moved into a standard header (standard being the operative word).

What a compiler expands as a built in is up to the compiler, and the flags that you pass to it when invoking it.

Keep in mind that gcc is not the only C compiler, but it (like others) conforms to c89 and c99.

Upvotes: 0

gnud
gnud

Reputation: 78568

Variable arguments today are done via the interface described in <stdarg.h> - as to how they were done 15 years ago, I really can't say.

Upvotes: 0

T.J. Crowder
T.J. Crowder

Reputation: 1074979

You're thinking of va_list, va_arg, va_start, and va_end from stdarg.h (link to WP article). They still work just fine. :-)

Upvotes: 5

Related Questions