CODEWITHSUNDEEP
rubyclass-designcoercioncoercetype-coercion
nonopolarity
nonopolarity

Reputation: 151076

In Ruby, can the coerce() method know what operator it is that requires the help to coerce?

In Ruby, it seems that a lot of coerce() help can be done by

def coerce(something)
  [self, something]
end

that's is, when

3 + rational

is needed, Fixnum 3 doesn't know how to handle adding a Rational, so it asks Rational#coerce for help by calling rational.coerce(3), and this coerce instance method will tell the caller:

# I know how to handle rational + something, so I will return you the following:
[self, something]
# so that now you can invoke + on me, and I will deal with Fixnum to get an answer

So what if most operators can use this method, but not when it is (a - b) != (b - a) situation? Can coerce() know which operator it is, and just handle those special cases, while just using the simple [self, something] to handle all the other cases where (a op b) == (b op a) ? (op is the operator).

Upvotes: 1

Views: 442

Answers (2)

Mladen Jablanović
Mladen Jablanović

Reputation: 44080

The point of coerce is not to know what operation you are trying to perform. Its purpose is to bring the argument and self to a common ground. Additionally, same operators can be commutative in certain classes, and not in other (Numeric#+ and Array#+, for example), so your small commutativity-based coerce exploit really won't pay off.

Instead of pushing your coerce to do what it's not intended to, you should create a new class instead (such as ScalarPoint, for example), and use it to interface scalar values with your Point:

class ScalarPoint
  attr_reader :val

  def initialize(val)
    @val = val
  end

  def +(arg)
    case arg
    when Point:
      Point.new(@val + arg.x, @val + arg.y)
    when ScalarPoint:
      ScalarPoint.new(arg.val + @val)
    else
      raise "Unknown operand!"
    end
  end

  # define other operators, such as * etc

  def coerce(arg)
    return [ScalarPoint.new(arg), self] if arg.is_a?(Numeric)
    raise "Can't handle"
  end
end

and

class Point
  def coerce(arg)
    [ScalarPoint.new(arg), self] if arg.is_a?(Numeric)
    raise "Can't handle"
  end
end

etc. (NB: code not tested)

Upvotes: 1

Marc-André Lafortune
Marc-André Lafortune

Reputation: 79572

The answer to this question is that you can know the operator by looking at the backtrace but you shouldn't do that.

That is not how the coerce mechanism of Ruby has been designed. As I answered in your previous question, coerce should return two equivalent values [a, b] such that a.send(operator, b) will work, whatever the operator.

Upvotes: 1

Related Questions