CODEWITHSUNDEEP
windowsprocessprocessors
Verim
Verim

Reputation: 1125

Why does Windows switch processes between processors?

If a single threaded process is busy and uses 100% of a single core it seems like Windows is switching this process between the cores, because in Task Managers core overview all cores are equal used.

Why does Windows do that? Isn't this destroying L1/L2 caches?

Upvotes: 18

Views: 3559

Answers (2)

nobody
nobody

Reputation: 20174

Your process may be the only one doing a lot of work, but it is not the only thing running. There are lots of other processes that need to run occasionally. When your process gets evicted and eventually re-scheduled, the core on which it was running previously might not be available. It's better to run the waiting process immediately on a free core than to wait for the previous core to be available (and in any case its data will likely have been bumped from the caches by the other thread).

In addition, modern CPUs allow all the cores in a package to share high-level caches. See the "Smart Cache" feature in this Intel Core i5 spec sheet. You still lose the lower-level cache(s) on core switch, but those are small and will probably churn somewhat anyway if you're running more than just a small tight loop.

Upvotes: 1

Ben Voigt
Ben Voigt

Reputation: 283893

There are advantages to pinning a process to one core, primarily caching which you already mentioned.

There are also disadvantages -- you get unequal heating, which can create mechanical stresses that do not improve the expected lifetime of the silicon die.

To avoid this, OSes tend to keep all cores at equal utilization. When there's only one active thread, it will have to be moved and invalidate caches. As long as this is done infrequently (in CPU time), the impact of the extra cache misses during migration is negligible.

For example, the abstract of "Energy and thermal tradeoffs in hardware-based load balancing for clustered multi-core architectures implementing power gating" explicitly lists this as a design goal of scheduling algorithms (emphasis mine):

In this work, a load-balancing technique for these clustered multi-core architectures is presented that provides both a low overhead in energy and an a smooth temperature distribution across the die, increasing the reliability of the processor by evenly stressing the cores.

Spreading the heat dissipation throughout the die is also essential for techniques such as Turbo Boost, where cores are clocked temporarily at a rate that is unsustainable long term. By moving load to a different core regularly, the average heat dissipation remains sustainable even though the instantaneous power is not.

Upvotes: 34

Related Questions