CODEWITHSUNDEEP
haskelltypes
bimmo
bimmo

Reputation: 395

Haskell: Can type variables be used within function definition?

I have a problem relating to the Haskell type system. This is not the first time I have encountered the type system's limitations. I will omit my project details and use a simplified example. Here is some code:

-- Works
foo :: (Bounded a, Enum a) => a
foo = minBound

-- "ambiguous" constraint:
-- 'a' has no occurrences in type declaration
bar :: (Bounded a, Enum a) => Int
bar = fromEnum minBound

-- Too much information in return
-- but I can show haskell the appropriate type of 'min'
baz :: (Bounded a, Enum a) => (a, Int)
baz = let min = minBound
    in (min, someFunction . fromEnum $ min)

-- Type constraint 'a' not ambiguous
--     (or at least that isn't the compiler error message)
-- but Haskell doesn't know which 'minBound' to use
barrer :: (Bounded a, Enum a) => a
barrer = let min = minBound -- <- min's type is ambiguous
    in toEnum . someFunction . fromEnum $ min

What I am trying to achieve is similar to barrer: First, use the minBound value specific to type a and 'cast' it to an integer. In my project, I proceed to transform this integer (to avoid intermediate arithmetic overflows when using type a) and 'cast' them back to type a (after a bit of mod magic). How can I tell Haskell the appropriate type of minBound? Is it possible?

The obvious solution is to add an annotation of minBound :: a. This would also fix bar. The problem: The type variable a seems to be out of scope in the function definition, as Haskell freshens minBound :: a to minBound a0 in the error message. Is there a way to do this type of annotation?

One bad hack I used was to constrain the type of the minBound call by including it in the function's return type, a la baz. This solution is not ideal. Does anyone have some advise?

Upvotes: 13

Views: 1090

Answers (1)

Yuriosity
Yuriosity

Reputation: 1918

The ScopedTypeVariables extension solves exactly your problem. The page also provides some alternative solutions (asTypeOf and undefined arguments).

Upvotes: 14

Related Questions