CODEWITHSUNDEEP
cgcc
Olof
Olof

Reputation: 533

Which 4.x version of gcc should one use?

The product-group I work for is currently using gcc 3.4.6 (we know it is ancient) for a large low-level c-code base, and want to upgrade to a later version. We have seen performance benefits testing different versions of gcc 4.x on all hardware platforms we tested it on. We are however very scared of c-compiler bugs (for a good reason historically), and wonder if anyone has insight to which version we should upgrade to.

Are people using 4.3.2 for large code-bases and feel that it works fine?

Upvotes: 6

Views: 1825

Answers (6)

vonbrand
vonbrand

Reputation: 11831

Use the latest one, but hunt down and understand each and every warning -Wall gives. For extra fun, there are more warning flags to frob. You do have an extensive suite of regression (and other) tests, run them all and check them.

GCC (particularly C++, but also C) has changed quite a bit. It does much better code analysis and optimization, and does handle code that turns out to invoke undefined bahaviiour differently. So code that "worked fine" but really did rely on some particular interpretation of invalid constructions will probably break. Hopefully making the compiler emit a warning or error, but no guarantee of such luck.

Upvotes: 1

Branan
Branan

Reputation: 1819

I can't say anything about 4.3.2, but my laptop is a Gentoo Linux system built with GCC 4.3.{0,1} (depending on when each package was built), and I haven't seen any problems. This is mostly just standard desktop use, though. If you have any weird code, your mileage may vary.

Upvotes: 0

nimish
nimish

Reputation: 4992

The best quality control for gcc is the linux kernel. GCC is the compiler of choice for basically all major open source C/C++ programs. A released GCC, especially one like 4.3.X, which is in major linux distros, should be pretty good.

GCC 4.3 also has better support for optimizations on newer cpus.

Upvotes: 4

dmo
dmo

Reputation: 4083

When I migrated a project from GCC 3 to GCC 4 I ran several tests to ensure that behavior was the same before and after. Can you just run a run a set of (hopefully automated) tests to confirm the correct behavior? After all, you want the "correct" behavior, not necessarily the GCC 3 behavior.

Upvotes: 4

KannoN
KannoN

Reputation: 362

If you are interested in OpenMP then you will need to move to gcc 4.2 or greater. We are using 4.2.2 on a code base of around 5M lines and are not having any problems with it.

Upvotes: 0

Bernard
Bernard

Reputation: 45539

I don't have a specific version for you, but why not have a 4.X and 3.4.6 installed? Then you could try and keep the code compiling on both versions, and if you run across a show-stopping bug in 4, you have an exit policy.

Upvotes: 1

Related Questions