CODEWITHSUNDEEP
javascriptajaxxmlhttprequestfetch-api
ilyabasiuk
ilyabasiuk

Reputation: 4650

Fetch API vs XMLHttpRequest

I know that Fetch API uses Promises and both of them allow you to do AJAX requests to a server.

I have read that Fetch API has some extra features, which aren't available in XMLHttpRequest (and in the Fetch API polyfill, since it's based on XHR).

What extra capabilities does the Fetch API have?

Upvotes: 312

Views: 183646

Answers (4)

JeffRSon
JeffRSon

Reputation: 11216

fetch, according to the specs, will throw a TypeError if the URL to be fetched contains credentials ("Request cannot be constructed from a URL that includes credentials").

This may sound reasonable (for security) and neglectable, because an additional "Authorization" header could be used if needed.

However, there's a problem if fetch inside a page shall load data relative to the base url of the page and if that page's URL has credentials itself. The browser will construct an URL for fetch('data.json') that contains credentials taken from the page and throw an error.

To me this appears like a browser bug - it's building the URL and could simply leave out credentials (what it does every other time anyway replacing it magically by "Authorisation" header). However, as it happens on both Chrome and Firefox, this may be intentional (although, IMO, the specs may leave room for another interpretation as well).

XMLHttpRequest, on the other hand, would load the requested resource happily even with credentials (see network tab in developer tools).

Hence, under certain circumstances, the behaviour of the page will change or even lead to an error - which we had to learn the hard way. We ended up building an absolute URL by using windows.location data.

Upvotes: 0

Knu
Knu

Reputation: 15144

fetch

  • missing a builtin method to consume documents
  • no way to set a timeout yet
  • can't override the content-type response header
  • if the content-length response header is present but not exposed, the body's total length is unknown during the streaming
  • will call the signal's abort handler even if the request has been completed
  • no upload progress (support for ReadableStream instances as request bodies is yet to come)
  • doesn't support --allow-file-access-from-files (chromium)

XHR

  • there's no way to not send cookies (apart from using the non-standard mozAnon flag or the AnonXMLHttpRequest constructor)
  • can't return FormData instances
  • doesn't have an equivalent to fetch's no-cors mode
  • always follows redirects

Upvotes: 113

Felipe
Felipe

Reputation: 12018

The answers above are good and provide good insights, but I share the same opinion as shared in this google developers blog entry in that the main difference (from a practical perspective) is the convenience of the built-in promise returned from fetch

Instead of having to write code like this

function reqListener() {
    var data = JSON.parse(this.responseText);
}

function reqError(err) { ... }

var oReq = new XMLHttpRequest();
oReq.onload = reqListener;
oReq.onerror = reqError;
oReq.open('get', './api/some.json', true);
oReq.send();

we can clean things up and write something a little more concise and readable with promises and modern syntax

fetch('./api/some.json')
    .then((response) => {
        response.json().then((data) => { 
            ... 
        });
    })
    .catch((err) => { ... });

Upvotes: 26

Marco Castelluccio
Marco Castelluccio

Reputation: 10802

There are a few things that you can do with fetch and not with XHR:

  • You can use the Cache API with the request and response objects;
  • You can perform no-cors requests, getting a response from a server that doesn't implement CORS. You can't access the response body directly from JavaScript, but you can use it with other APIs (e.g. the Cache API);
  • Streaming responses (with XHR the entire response is buffered in memory, with fetch you will be able to access the low-level stream). This isn't available yet in all browsers, but will be soon.

There are a couple of things that you can do with XHR that you can't do yet with fetch, but they're going to be available sooner or later (read the "Future improvements" paragraph here: https://hacks.mozilla.org/2015/03/this-api-is-so-fetching/):

  • Abort a request (this now works in Firefox and Edge, as @sideshowbarker explains in his comment);
  • Report progress.

This article https://jakearchibald.com/2015/thats-so-fetch/ contains a more detailed description.

Upvotes: 215

Related Questions