CODEWITHSUNDEEP
perlif-statementswitch-statement
yoniyes
yoniyes

Reputation: 1030

switch vs. given vs. for-when vs. if-elsif-else in Perl

In one of the last scripts I wrote, I needed a behavior similar to a switch statement behavior. A simple search of an equivalent in Perl led me to use Switch. At the beginning, all was fine and working, until everything just crashed with errors that are not very descriptive (it happened on a switch statement that had cases with regex, but strangely it didn't happen on other switch statements that are alike).

EDIT: the code that crashed was looking like this one:

switch ($var) {
    case /pattern1/ {...}
    case /pattern2/ {...}
    ...
    else {...}
}

That led me to abandon the use of Switch.pm and search for an alternative.

I found given and for-when and of course there's always the straightforward and somewhat naive if-elsif-else.

  1. Why is Switch.pm so unstable?
  2. It seems given and for-when have a similar structure, but I guess there's a difference (because both exist). What is it?
  3. Is if-elsif-else significantly slower than the other options?

Upvotes: 4

Views: 3310

Answers (1)

ikegami
ikegami

Reputation: 386331

Perl's when and smart-matching are experimental, and they won't become features without backward-incompatible changes. You should not use these.

Switch.pm is a source filter, so it can produce incorrect error message when something's wrong. It also suffers from the same problems as smart-matching. You should not use this.

So, of the options you listed, only one is viable, and it's not any slower at all!

Upvotes: 8

Related Questions