CODEWITHSUNDEEP
windows-installerinstallaware
MrB
MrB

Reputation: 4515

What's the difference between an EXE and a MSI installer?

I've created an installation package using Installaware and generated an EXE and a MSI. The EXE is 3.1MB and the MSI is only 265K. Why is there such a big difference in size?

Upvotes: 28

Views: 31387

Answers (3)

Stein Åsmul
Stein Åsmul

Reputation: 42246

UPDATE: Some resources with information on how to handle various types of setup.exe files:

MSI File: An MSI file can only be launched by msiexec.exe - The Windows Installer Engine. An MSI file is a Windows Installer database file capable of installing software. It requires the right version of the Windows Installer Engine Runtime at the very minimum to be installable. Most systems are up to date with the latest engine versions since it comes down via Windows Update.

EXE File: The EXE file you generate is a self-extracting launcher application containing both the MSI itself as well as various runtime requirements that the setup might have. Various components an EXE file might include:

  • The version of the Windows Installer Engine Runtime the MSI requires (current version 5.0). These days this runtime should be installed by Windows Update, and your setup should just verify it is present.
  • Scripting runtimes required by custom actions in the MSI (Installscript for Installshield).
  • The .NET runtime version required by the application. I would prefer using Windows Update for this as well, but if your application is cutting edge, you might want to include the required engine. Can you set it to download rather than embedding? You can also supply it as a separate download.
  • Logo files and splash screens, potentially in different languages for multi-lingual setups.
  • Several other components are possible.

Legacy Setup.exe Installer: Note that an EXE file can also be a non-MSI installer In other words an old-style installer not based on the Microsoft MSI format (which is a MS-SQL database stored in an office-style binary file), but rather an installation script of various formats such as Wise Script, Installscript, Inno Setup, NSIS, etc... However, in this case the question was about the difference in size between the EXE and the MSI coming out of an InstallAware build, and then the difference is the runtimes explained above.

Upvotes: 30

Jas
Jas

Reputation: 1141

The difference is : MSI package contains your files + install script, and the actual installation is run by the Microsoft Installer which is a part of Windows, and it takes care of displaying Windows, logging messages etc. On the other hand, your EXE installer is holding files + actual program logic to run the install itself, being responsible for pretty much everything, hence the difference.

Upvotes: 9

Jim Brissom
Jim Brissom

Reputation: 32969

The EXE probably contains setup routines that are otherwise performed by msiexec, which just executes whatever installation script is contained in the MSI.

Upvotes: -7

Related Questions