CODEWITHSUNDEEP
mysqlsql-server-2005postgresqloracle10gdb2
RKh
RKh

Reputation: 14161

Help me select RDBMS for a standalone app. Few Concerns

My app. is in C# 3.5 and MySQL 5.1. It is a Windows based standalone application. It is running successfully since last two years except few issues and that too were later found out to be MySQL bugs. The bug disturbed the real-time reports as it store the same timestamp in two rows.

I don't know whether MySQL fixed it or not so I want to get rid of this. Now the options are:

SQL Server 2005/2008 Express, Oracle 10g Express, DB2 9.2 Express, PostgreSQL, MS Access or SQLite.

Starting with the obvious choices: MS Access & SQLite. The problem with MS Access is that the MDB gets corrupted is a sudden power failure occurs and the file is not repairable. This happened with us on a production DB.

The problem with SQLite is that it's GUI still doesn't have rich query browser and also you cannot create composite keys through GUI. Secondly, I never used it and can't take chance. I don't know how many constraints it supports.

Coming to the rest. SQL Server is good, but people here at SO said that it has its own set of bugs. Also it limits database size. Oracle, even though Express Edition, needs sooner or later a DBA, if something goes wrong.

I have not used IBM DB2 but people say that it is a very robust database and its GUI is feature rich. Apart from that it is very easy to manage and has no size limits. Same is true with PostgreSQL, but GUI not so feature rich, however it is sufficient. I don't know how it's licensing works. The other problem is that its .NET connector is not fast. It works slow as compared to its ODBC connector.

Your valuable insights and recommendations are welcome.

Upvotes: 0

Views: 242

Answers (2)

David Sky
David Sky

Reputation: 59

I work at IBM on DB2 LUW, so of course I'm biased, but if you do decide to give DB2 a try here's the details on Building .NET applications in Visual Basic and C# complete with compile and link options.

Upvotes: 0

Kuberchaun
Kuberchaun

Reputation: 30324

Being you ruled out Access and express additions for their limited data size there is really no reason not to use Postgres even if you hadn't ruled the others out. See my answer to the question below along with the others who answered.

SQL Server Express alternatives beyond 2GB limit

Cystal Reports http://wiki.postgresql.org/wiki/PostgreSQL_and_Crystal_Reports

Upvotes: 3

Related Questions