What is the difference between Amazon ECS and Amazon EC2?

Question

I'm just getting started on AWS EC2. I understand that EC2 is like a remote computer where I can do pretty much everything I want. Then I found out about ECS. I know it uses Docker, but I'm confused about the relationship between these two.

Is ECS just a Docker install in EC2? If I already have an EC2 and I start an ECS, does it mean I have two instances?

Answer 1

Amazon EC2 : -It allows you to create virtual machines, known as instances, and run applications on them. -With EC2, you have full control over the virtual machine's operating system, configuration, and software installations.

Amazon ECS: -Amazon ECS is a fully managed container orchestration service that allows you to run, scale, and manage Docker containers in the cloud.

• ECS abstracts away the complexity of managing individual EC2 instances and lets you focus on running and scaling your containers.

Answer 2

Amazon ECS stands for “Elastic Container Service.” Where EC2 uses virtualization and virtual machines (VMs), Amazon ECS is used to manage Docker container applications. It is a fully managed container orchestration service that functions in similar fashion to Kubernetes. Amazon ECS orchestrates Docker containers running via Amazon EC2.

Amazon EC2 stands for “elastic compute cloud.” EC2 allows enterprises to access cloud computing resources on demand. There are over 500 instances to choose from, with the latest processor, storage, operating system, and networking technologies.

Amazon EC2 is akin to a managed virtual machine (VM) service, where preconfigured VM instances can be deployed without the management burden. Enterprises can also upload on-premises VM configurations to EC2 with automated conversion and deployment in the cloud via VM export/import.

Answer 3

EC2 & ECS are compute services which means they both can host applications.

1.What is it ?

a) EC2 -> EC2 is a remote/virtual Computer. You can install any s/w (e.g Oracle ) on it & manage it yourself or can install managed service solutions like (e.g.RDS,DynamoDB) as well. b) ECS is a managed container service to run Docker.You can run ECS on either (set of EC2 instances) or serverless option Far-gate.

2. Hosting

a) Hosting an application on E2 instances directly ,involves Load balancer, Auto scaling & EC2 instance. It gives you a choice to select from your type of instance you want (Compute optimized or memory optimized etc.

b) In ECS, you get a set of (EC2 instances or far gate) called Cluster, & tasks are deployed on these clusters. Auto Scaling happens by itself.

2. Use Case

a) For a solution ,where you want to control type & scaling up/down & security of your application .In addition you want the flexibility of running hybrid solutions & want to control cost by spinning up & terminating instances at your will. Creating self managed solution using EC2 is an option

b) For docker based solutions ,where you want to visualise your work in terms of tasks, that run on clusters (which are set of docker containers running on EC2 instances) , ECS is a solution , It scales automatically based on load & saves the effort but is a bit on the expensive side as compared to self managed solutions ,unless human effort is accounted as well.

Answer 4

EC2 is a compute service that enables applications to run on AWS, whereas ECS is an AWS service used primarily to orchestrate Docker containers.

Answer 5

ECS is a container orchestrator just like Kubernetes or Docker swarm, EC2 is an Amazon Elastic Compute Cloud platform for Creating Virtual Machines. ECS allows you to run containers on either serverless environments (Fargate) where you don't have to run any VM or in a non managed environments where you host the containers on EC2 instances.

Answer 6

In simple words,ECS is a manager while EC2 instances are just like employees. All the employees (EC2) under this manager(ECS) can perform "Docker" tasks and the manager also understands "docker" pretty well. So,whenever you need "docker" resources, you show up to the Manager. Manager already has status from every employee(EC2) decides which one should perform the task.

Now, coming back to your question, a manager without an "employee" does not make sense but is definitely possible.

Answer 7

ECS stands for 'Elastic Container Service'. It is a container orchestration service.
Lets say you have a Docker container running and you decide to update the Docker image. It's relatively easy task to stop, pull and run if you have one container running but its tedious to do the same steps if you have 10 to 100 of containers running.
With AWS ECS you can have this control. You specify if update is required provide the latest image id and ECS will handle the stop, pull and run etc. commands for you. It also provides with much more additional features, refer - https://aws.amazon.com/ecs/features/
EC2 stand for 'Elastic Compute Cloud'. In simple terms its a virtual machine.
ECS uses EC2 to run your containers.
'These running docker containers (tasks) are run on EC2 instances'.

Answer 8

Okay, as you know EC2 is a virtual machine on AWS and ECS is a container orchestration system on AWS.

To use ECS, you need to run your container into some virtual machines which EC2 is one of an option to provide that.

You will need to install ecs-agent on EC2 to make a connection with ECS. And ECS also can monitor the resource usages on your EC2. So basically you choose the more high-level EC2 type, then more resource(CPU/MEM) your container can use.

Answer 9

Put simply, Elastic Container Service (ECS) is a Docker container orchestration service.

You can ask it to run one or more Docker images, either as an auto-scaling capable "Service" or as an ad-hoc "Task".

The services and tasks run on a "Cluster". Originally, a Cluster was a group of one or more pre-configured EC2 servers running ECS Cluster Agent. The Cluster Agent would schedule the containers on the EC2 server. These EC2 servers show up in your EC2 Instances list and are charged at regular EC2 per-minute costs - You can even SSH onto them like any normal EC2 server. If you wanted more capacity to run more Services or Tasks, or if you wanted resilience against EC2 failure, then you would more EC2 servers.

Around November 2017, AWS added ECS Fargate. Now a Cluster can run "serverless" without provisioning EC2 nodes. You simply define the amount of CPU and memory your Task or Service requires to operate, meaning that you just pay for the CPU and memory time rather than the EC2.

Answer 10

Your question

Is ECS just a docker install in EC2? If I already have a EC2, then I start a ECS, does it mean I have two instance?

No. AWS ECS is just a logical grouping (cluster) of EC2 instances, and all the EC2 instances part of an ECS act as Docker host i.e. ECS can send command to launch a container on them (EC2). If you already have an EC2, and then launch ECS, you'll still have a single instance. If you add/register (by installing the AWS ECS Container Agent) the EC2 to ECS it'll become the part of the cluster, but still a single instance of EC2.

An Amazon ECS without any EC2 registered (added to the cluster) is good for nothing.

---

TL; DR

An overview

• EC2 - is simply a remote (virtual) machine.
• ECS stands for Elastic Container Service - as per basic definition of computer cluster, ECS is basically a logical grouping of EC2 machines/instances. Technically speaking ECS is a mere configuration for an efficient use and management of your EC2 instance(s) resources i.e. storage, memory, CPU, etc.

---

To simplify it further, if you have launched an Amazon ECS with no EC2 instances added to it, it's good for nothing i.e. you can't do anything about it. ECS makes sense only once one (or more) EC2 instances are added to it.

The next confusing thing here is the container term - which is not fully virtualized machine instances, and Docker is one technology we can use to create container instances. Docker is a utility you can install on our machine, which makes it a Docker host, and on this host you can create containers (same as virtual machines - but much more light-weight). To sum up, ECS is just about clustering of EC2 instances, and uses Docker to instantiate containers/instances/virtual machines on these (EC2) hosts.

All you need to do is launch an ECS, and register/add as much EC2 instances to it as you need. You can add/register EC2 instances, all you need is Amazon ECS Container Agent running on your EC2 instance/machine, which can be done manually or directly using the special AMI (Amazon Machine Image) i.e. Amazon ECS-optimized AMI, which already has the Amazon ECS Container Agent. During the launch of a new EC2 instance the Agent automatically registers it to the default ECS cluster.

The container agent running on each of the instances (EC2 instances) within an Amazon ECS cluster sends information about the instance's current running tasks and resource utilization to Amazon ECS, and starts and stops tasks whenever it receives a request from Amazon ECS. For more information, see Amazon ECS Container Agent. Once set, each of the created container instances (of whatever EC2 machine/node) will be an instance in Amazon ECS's swarm.

---

For more information – read step 10 from this documentation: Launching an Amazon ECS Container Instance:

Choose an AMI for your container instance. You can choose the Amazon ECS-optimized AMI, or another operating system, such as CoreOS or Ubuntu. If you do not choose the Amazon ECS-optimized AMI, you need to follow the procedures in Installing the Amazon ECS Container Agent.

By default, your container instance launches into your default cluster. If you want to launch into your own cluster instead of the default, choose the Advanced Details list and paste the following script into the User data field, replacing your_cluster_name with the name of your cluster.

#!/bin/bash
echo ECS_CLUSTER=your_cluster_name >> /etc/ecs/ecs.config

Or, if you have an ecs.config file in Amazon S3 and have enabled Amazon S3 read-only access to your container instance role, choose the Advanced Details list and paste the following script into the User data field, replacing your_bucket_name with the name of your bucket to install the AWS CLI and write your configuration file at launch time. Note For more information about this configuration, see Storing Container Instance Configuration in Amazon S3.

#!/bin/bash
yum install -y aws-cli
aws s3 cp s3://your_bucket_name/ecs.config /etc/ecs/ecs.config

---

Just to clarify it further – you can create containers on your single EC2 instance without ECS. Install any of the containerization technology i.e. Docker and run the create container command, setting your EC2 as a Docker host, and have as much Docker containers as you want (or as much as your EC2's resources allow).

Answer 11

EC2 allows you to launch individual instances which you can use for pretty much whatever you like. ECS is a container service, which means it will launch instances that will be ready to launch container applications. The main distinction between the two services is that with EC2 you have to manage each instance separately in whatever method you choose (manually, using a CM tool or any other way) - deploy your applications and maintain the connection between the servers yourself. ECS allows you to launch a cluster of machines that will serve as the deployment ground of your container apps, allowing you to treat all instances in the cluster as one big instance available for your container workload.

And to answer your question - You can start an ECS cluster with no instances in it, but then it won't be able to run anything on it. Once you register an EC2 instance inside an ECS cluster, containers are ready to run in it. So the bottom line is - you can use both ECS and EC2 with only one instance, but that is not the actual use case these services were built for.