CSS variables with fallback for older browsers

Question

TL;DR: How can you use SCSS to have CSS variables with a fallback for older browsers.

I'm trying to make sense of this article. In my opinion, you have to already be an advanced SASS user to understand it, which I'm not. To make matters worse, it's the only article I found on the subject.

Here is what I'm trying to achieve:

My scss should be along the lines of :

body {
  @include v(background-color, primary)
}

then the processed CSS should be

body{
   background: yellow; /* Yellow being defined above as the primary color */
   background: var(--color-primary);
}

By playing around a bit, I can already get the value of the CSS variable like so:

$colors: (
  primary: yellow,
);

:root {
  @each $name, $color in $colors {
    --color-#{$name}: $color;
  }
}

@mixin background-color($color_) {
  background: var(--color-#{$color_});
}

To use it:

body{
  @include background-color(primary);
}

Which will result in this:

body {
    background: var(--color-primary);
    /* But the fallback is missing :(, I tried  things with the map-get but it's really eluding me... */
}

Answer 1

Update: Postcss Custom properties can do fallback and is way easier than the below code

step 1: declare scss variables

So first of all we want to put some variables in a $map, I'll go with color variables:

$colors: (
  primary: #FFBB00,
  secondary: #0969A2
);

step 2: automate css 4 var generation

// ripped CSS4 vars out of color map
:root {
  // each item in color map
  @each $key, $value in $colors {
    --colors-#{$key}: $value;
  }
}

What happens in root is : for each key and value in the colors map, we print the followng :

--colors-#{$key}: $value;

Which corresponds to css variable declarations. I believe the weird bit with #{} around the key is to not have spaces around the value. Thus the result is:

--colors-primary: #FFBB00,
--colors-secondary: #0969A2

Note that the prefix (--colors-) is the same name as the scss color map above it. The why will become clear in last step.

---

step 3: Plenty of maps !

$props: (
  background-color: $colors
);

$map-maps: (
  background-color: colors
);

Here we add the map $props which maps a css property to the map containing the values. background-color will hold color, so the correct map is $colors.

map-maps is a copy of props where instead of the map we have the name of said map. (this is relative to the note in step 2).

Step 4 : let's make it work !

@mixin v($prop, $var) {
  // get the map from map name
  $map: map-get($props, $prop);
  // fallback value, grab the variable's value from the map
  $var-fall: map-get($map, $var);
  // our css4 variable output
  $var-output: var(--#{$map}-#{$var});    
  #{$prop}: $var-fall;
  // css4 variable output
  #{$prop}: $var-output;
}

body{
  @include v(background-color, primary);
}

I simplified the code in the article quite a bit, it still works, for this example at least, the code in the article takes more into account.

Anyhow, here is what happens.

First, we call the mixin with:

  @include v(background-color, primary);

Then upon entering,

 $map: map-get($props, $prop); // map-get($props, background-color)

we have a variable called $map to which we assign the value that is inside the $props map at the key background-color which happen to be the $colors map. It's a bit of a maze but it's not that complicated once you resolve it.

Then for the fallback:

 $var-fall: map-get($map, $var);

This simply gets the value of the map we just got (which is $colors) at the $var key (which happens to be primary). Thus the result is #FFBB00.

For the css var

  $map-name: map-get($map-maps, $prop);
  $var-output: var(--#{$map-name}-#{$var});

we recreate what we did to generate the var in the @each loop

---

Whole code would be :

$colors: (
  primary: #FFBB00,
  secondary: #0969A2
);

// ripped CSS4 vars out of color map
:root {
  // each item in color map
  @each $name, $color in $colors {
    --colors-#{$name}: $color;
  }
}



$props: (
  background-color: $colors,
  color:            $colors
);

$map-maps: (
  background-color: colors
);



@mixin v($prop, $var) {
  // get the map from map name
  $map: map-get($props, $prop);
  // fallback value, grab the variable's value from the map
  $var-fall: map-get($map, $var);
  // our css4 variable output

  $map-name: map-get($map-maps, $prop);
  $var-output: var(--#{$map-name}-#{$var});

  #{$prop}: $var-fall;
  // css4 variable output
  #{$prop}: $var-output;
}

body{
  @include v(background-color, primary);
}

---

Now this is a simplification of what is done in the article. You should check it out to have code a bit more robust.

Answer 2

If you're using Sass, you can automate fallbacks through a Sass mixin. Create a map of your CSS variable names and their values, and then you can look up those values in a mixin that outputs the fallback style and the preferred one

$vars: (
  primary: yellow,
);

:root {
  --primary: map-get($vars, primary);
}

@mixin var($property, $varName) {
  #{$property}: map-get($vars, $varName);
  #{$property}: var(--#{$varName});
}

The above mixin is used like so:

body {
  @include var(background-color, primary);
}

and outputs the following CSS:

:root {
  --primary: yellow;
}

body {
  background-color: yellow;
  background-color: var(--primary);
}

Et voilà :)

Answer 3

I assume you are aware of the reason why it didn't show the fallback. But since it's an answer I will explain the reasons

The current mixin block has only one background property which makes the sass compiler to generate only one property. I don't think sass can identify whether 'var' is supported in browser or not. So, we have to explicitly specify if we need the fallback.

Since you already have the map all you need is to get the value by giving the key 'primary'

 @mixin background-color($color_) {
      background: var(--color-#{$color_});  
      background: map-get($colors, primary);
    }

This will add the background: yellow to the body class always. Alternatively if you want to control the addition of the fallback based on condition. You can do like this

@mixin background-color($color_, $showFall) {
  background: var(--color-#{$color_});  
  @if $showFall {
    background: map-get($colors, primary);
  }
}

and call like this

body{
  @include background-color(primary, true);
}

Code pen for the same https://codepen.io/srajagop/pen/xdovON

Note: I am writing the answer under the assumption that you want only the background-color to work and not all the other properties like mentioned in that post. For that you need to create a proper data structure