CODEWITHSUNDEEP
c++arrays
pio
pio

Reputation: 540

why multidimensional array must have bounds when I specify it in the initialization in cpp

when trying to initialize a multidimensional array like this:

int a[][] = { {1,2,3},
              {4,5,6} };

I get this error:

error: declaration of iArray as multidimensional array must have bounds for all dimensions except the first

but I want to understand why, the compiler should know it's a[2][3] array because of the {}.

I know that is allowed also to do:

int a[][3] = {1,2,3,4,5,6};

and for that case indeed the compiler can't guess what is the 2nd dimension if it missing, but why not to allow the use of a[][] in the first case?

Upvotes: 10

Views: 9015

Answers (2)

Jacek Cz
Jacek Cz

Reputation: 1906

C++ array is continuous block of cells, rows (in this example) starting at 3th, 6th. Without size declaration this cannot be done.

Creators of standard / compiler want to check initialisers against declaration - and not to guess from multiple initialisers, maybe some with typos errors. I think, guessing sizes for over 3,4 dimensions with variable initialisation lengths is too hard? EDIT: agree with molbdnilo comment, compiler simplification

If You have some training in Java/C# (or high level object implementations like std::vector), must think in C style.

EDIT: One dimension array, declared explicitly or by initialisation in both options is very simple C linear structure (i.e. can be accessed at negative or beyond size index). To tell the true, compiled code have NOT dependencies on size, this knowledge is not used.

Upvotes: 4

Martin Bonner supports Monica
Martin Bonner supports Monica

Reputation: 28987

[Shrug] That's just the way it is.

You could propose changing the standard to allow this. You would need to:

  • write a specification
  • explain why this is worth adding additional complexity (to both standard and implementations).
  • probably modify an existing implementation to add this as an extension.

It's not obvious to me that this would have many gotcha's, but on the other hand, it's also not obvious how much of a benefit it would be (adding extra support for raw arrays is probably pretty low on everyone's mind).

Upvotes: 6

Related Questions