CODEWITHSUNDEEP
rregex
Scarabee
Scarabee

Reputation: 5704

Unexpected match of regex

I expect the regex pattern ab{,2}c to match only with a followed by 0, 1 or 2 bs, followed by c.

It works that way in lots of languages, for instance Python. However, in R:

grepl("ab{,2}c", c("ac", "abc", "abbc", "abbbc", "abbbbc"))
# [1]  TRUE  TRUE  TRUE  TRUE FALSE

I'm surprised by the 4th TRUE. In ?regex, I can read:

{n,m} The preceding item is matched at least n times, but not more than m times.

So I agree that {,2} should be written {0,2} to be a valid pattern (unlike in Python, where the docs state explicitly that omitting n specifies a lower bound of zero).

But then using {,2} should throw an error instead of returning misleading matches! Am I missing something or should this be reported as a bug?

Upvotes: 12

Views: 481

Answers (3)

Andre Elrico
Andre Elrico

Reputation: 11480

Just as an addition:

vec1 = c('','a', 'aa', 'aaa', 'aaaa', 'aaaaa', 'aaaaaa','aaaaaaa')

grep("^a{,1}$", vec1, value = T) # seems to "become" ^a{1}$
grep("^a{,2}$", vec1, value = T) # seems to "become" ^a{0,3}$
grep("^a{,3}$", vec1, value = T) # seems to "become" ^a{0,4}$
grep("^a{,4}$", vec1, value = T) # seems to "become" ^a{0,5}$

Upvotes: 3

Plamen Petrov
Plamen Petrov

Reputation: 327

I am writing this as an answer, because unfortunately I cant add a comment.

Update: Following the answer by Wiktor Stribiżew and feedback, seems the behavior is categories as a bug.

Original: The syntax you are using is just not supported in R (assuming the default engine). This is why you are getting unexpected results.

  • The supported syntax is {n,m} as the documentation states. Thus, you need to specify both boundaries, e.g. {0,2}, which will return the correct result.
  • The syntax {,m}, on the other hand, is missing from the documentation to regex, which silently indicates that it is not supported.

In case you would like to explore differences in syntax, I would recommend taking a look at the regular-expressions.info comparison page. (You need to compare Python and R in terms of Quantifiers in this case.)

Upvotes: 0

Wiktor Stribiżew
Wiktor Stribiżew

Reputation: 626758

The behavior with {,2} is not expected, it is a bug. If you have a look at the TRE source code, tre_parse_bound method, you will see that the min variable value is set to -1 before the engine tries to initialize the minimum bound. It seems that the number of "repeats" in case the minimum value is missing in the quantifier is the number of maximum value + 1 (as if the repeat number equals max - min = max - (-1) = max+1).

So, a{,} matches one occurrence of a. Same as a{, } or a{ , }. See R demo, only abc is matched with ab{,}c:

grepl("ab{,}c", c("ac", "abc", "abbc", "abbbc", "abbbbc"))
grepl("ab{, }c", c("ac", "abc", "abbc", "abbbc", "abbbbc"))
grepl("ab{ ,   }c", c("ac", "abc", "abbc", "abbbc", "abbbbc"))
## => [1] FALSE  TRUE FALSE FALSE FALSE

Upvotes: 10

Related Questions