CODEWITHSUNDEEP
routesosrm
Talha K.
Talha K.

Reputation: 27

Osrm Routing Not Working

I want to make routing between 5 coordinates but osrm route service not working.

my request to the server; https://router.project-osrm.org/route/v1/driving/28.0705,41.1813;22.5441,40.0051;28.3865,39.1073;22.6612,40.0330;27.3865,40.0151

response from server;

{
"routes": [
    {
        "geometry": "ybjzFcdijD}}BuqAhhOcmRfb[ham@mlFnfj@nsKf`q@uzBpnPxvEx|b@plK`p`@sdA~kuB_tKt{Ruf@vvOvcEzdS}u@vfYpgLr~o@_{l@~ez@enDjdYzZl~{@f`Jlu[ad@bhQjiNxtU~qDzan@pyOdiQk}@bkLnbQz}k@o`@bc_@zxVj}l@qhD~bn@|tBhcTkuIjen@xhGljKfa@pcTzfFuRlsVllr@~p^ilDpmQjpOhqp@q~IriBlzErhCby@mwB_sKoht@f{M{uQypOof]x_EuuLeoQs_Jer`@ajFvVk]}yS}pGw~LvyI_{l@_uBgbT|gDuen@wwVsxl@n`@eb_@ubQe_l@p|@qnLsxOmfQuqDq_n@gjNqxUlb@woQo}Iq`[_\\kk|@~mDedYr~l@qh|@wkLc`n@tv@acYycE_cS`f@oxOrtKm{RzdAwiuB{lKwr`@qvEg}b@rzBymPwuKusq@jrFgdi@kbK_pLocPmzi@|aM{sg@e}I_kYhiI_yQyjHuh~@fbAi`QdcG{vFaBsu[h{FzB~mCgsIt~FzfBtz[mle@fzJqXrqR~pWrx_@vgMfiIvl_@xsNfpDxjHpsPhmPad~@liJo{Ef`Wc`r@l}JmxAh`Kmwc@gaDc{]hmSqfe@jnf@`lHlzGvnOfyYdkNtbKofM~cPrmSldNle_Ah~s@df_A_fFtuUakVpxZ{jFxld@ck@zkYjvIw~@bcWpki@yvWllXxvWmlXccWqki@kvIv~@bk@{kYzjFyld@`kVqxZ~eFuuUi~s@ef_AmdNme_Ag`PgvSqmKh_M{qY{{McxGenOamf@orHarSjke@jaDl|]eaKlyc@u|JnvA}_W|_r@kdKjqFipOpb}@}kHaiPsoNwiDcmIur_@kx_@}gMuxR{rWw|JzVypFpzPafT~tSwzFigBapCpuIm{FiIhEnz[edG|wFmaAfjQrjHba~@{hIvuQn}I~fYkvLrgp@dz[rwn@ioFt{i@nsKf`q@uzBpnPxvEx|b@plK`p`@sdA~kuB_tKt{Ruf@vvOvcEzdS}u@vfYzjLp|m@i~l@`h|@enDjdY`\\pk|@`_Jhh[ad@bhQjiNxtU~qDzan@pyOdiQk}@bkLnbQz}k@o`@bc_@zxVj}l@qhD~bn@|tBhcTqyIt{l@~lGbtLfa@pcT`fF_T|xOlok@toLpoHr{Wq~F|tQbpOvri@i~E`hK}cLihKzbL{oi@j}Eg{QipOqvWt}F{lMwcJ_yNq|i@m_GsYkGofR}pGw~LvyI_{l@_uBgbTvhDcan@ewVcyl@b_@gf_@ubQe_l@v{@mqLywOqcQksD{en@elNa~U`f@}cQa~Iwe[i]mez@n}Dmb\\|ll@key@ytP{m~A`f@oxOrsK_tR|]gui@~rEd`AdlWohUjyOovXlqXzj_@~}OltHj{EqbKubDyoe@jtKmiNdcRkwr@hhWgPpfIaqHzaX~uGwbFibXgvGbcB",
        "legs": [
            {
                "summary": "",
                "weight": 59053.3,
                "duration": 29868.5,
                "steps": [],
                "distance": 633021.8
            },
            {
                "summary": "",
                "weight": 98982.7,
                "duration": 60860.9,
                "steps": [],
                "distance": 1270431
            },
            {
                "summary": "",
                "weight": 85723.3,
                "duration": 54659.9,
                "steps": [],
                "distance": 1255026.5
            },
            {
                "summary": "",
                "weight": 80038.7,
                "duration": 39865,
                "steps": [],
                "distance": 668853.2
            }
        ],
        "weight_name": "routability",
        "weight": 323798,
        "duration": 185254.3,
        "distance": 3827332.5
    }
],
"waypoints": [
    {
        "hint": "AFmhh4uHV4iAAgAAPgAAAIcBAAAAAAAAQAEAAB8AAADDAAAAAAAAAKPfAAAvS6wBZl50AmRSrAF0YHQCAgA_FTrv2WQ=",
        "name": "",
        "location": [
            28.068655,
            41.180774
        ]
    },
    {
        "hint": "F4gUhJHWs4QcAAAAQQAAALV8AABiNAAADQAAACEAAABdPgAAOBoAAKPfAAAH-FcB_m9iAuT-VwHsbWICzABfATrv2WQ=",
        "name": "",
        "location": [
            22.542343,
            40.00563
        ]
    },
    {
        "hint": "fIxchNifEYd3AAAAAAAAACFKAAAAAAAAOwAAAAAAAAAbJQAAAAAAAKPfAAB7E7EB-1hUAsQksQHkulQCiwCPEjrv2WQ=",
        "name": "",
        "location": [
            28.382075,
            39.082235
        ]
    },
    {
        "hint": "S4UOhLRX8YmHBAAAAAAAAMEAAAAAAAAAQwIAAAAAAABgAAAAAAAAAKPfAAA9OFkBdkNiAlDIWQHo2mICAwDfATrv2WQ=",
        "name": "",
        "location": [
            22.624317,
            39.99423
        ]
    },
    {
        "hint": "bsy0hnvMtIZ0AAAAPgAAAOsIAACDKwAAOgAAAB8AAAB0BAAAxBUAAKPfAAB8u6EB1JhiAoTioQH8lGICEgB_ADrv2WQ=",
        "name": "",
        "location": [
            27.376508,
            40.016084
        ]
    }
],
"code": "Ok"

}

1.location : 28.0705,41.1813 2.location : 22.5441,40.0051 3.location : 28.3865,39.1073 4.location : 22.6612,40.0330 5.location : 27.3865,40.0151

if we want to route between these points, does not it have to come out as follows 1.location : 28.0705,41.1813 3.location : 28.3865,39.1073 5.location : 27.3865,40.0151 4.location : 22.6612,40.0330 2.location : 22.5441,40.0051

Osrm can not direct to the shortest distance ?

Upvotes: 0

Views: 963

Answers (2)

Louie Lee
Louie Lee

Reputation: 283

I ran into this question and according to their discussion on GitHub, it seems like the reason is that OSRM considers different types of roads with different speeds. Thus, it routes the fastest route rather than the shortest route.

Upvotes: 0

DeepProblems
DeepProblems

Reputation: 607

There is nothing weird there. It's a route, so it will considere you have to go to your location with a precise order. So it won't change the order.

It is written in the api : " Route service Finds the fastest route between coordinates in the supplied order. "

If you want to order it, i'm not sure OSRM is the best tool for this but there is the "Trip service" that might do the job.

Have a nice day.

Upvotes: 2

Related Questions