CODEWITHSUNDEEP
clojureprotocols
Rob Lachlan
Rob Lachlan

Reputation: 14459

Can Clojure's protocol functions be variadic like ordinary functions?

With clojure functions, I can define:

(defn f [x & xs] (apply some-function x xs))

I'm attempting to do this same sort of thing with a protocol, e.g.

(defprotocol foo
  (bar [f])
  (baz [f & gs]))

This compiles (at least in the REPL), but any implementing type seems to fail on this (the variadic, baz) method. Is this officially not supported? The sources that I've consulted are silent.

Upvotes: 11

Views: 2324

Answers (2)

amalloy
amalloy

Reputation: 91897

This is not supported, for the reasons Stuart Sierra gives. To go into a little more detail, the & symbol is special only in a destructuring context like let or function arguments. As Stuart makes clear, defprotocol is not such a context.

But & is still a legal symbol, so you've defined a protocol with two functions: bar takes one argument, named f, and baz takes three, named f, &, and gs.

Upvotes: 12

Alex Ott
Alex Ott

Reputation: 87154

As answered Stuart Sierra in following thread, variadic methods aren't supported, and possibly will not supported in the future

Upvotes: 10

Related Questions