CODEWITHSUNDEEP
bashescaping
mpen
mpen

Reputation: 282845

How to echo the literal string "-e" (and nothing else) in bash?

How can I echo the literal string -e and nothing else?

I'm trying to better understand how shell arguments are escaped.

The following commands do not work:

echo -e # prints nothing
echo '-e' # prints nothing
echo "-e" # prints nothing
echo \-e # prints nothing
echo \\-e # prints \-e
echo '\-e' # prints \-e
echo "'-e'" # prints '-e' (with quotes)
echo -- -e # prints -- -e

I can't find one that doesn't either include quotes or a leading slash.

Upvotes: 7

Views: 1567

Answers (4)

that other guy
that other guy

Reputation: 123450

I'm assuming the real question is why:

A C# or Java function can never behave differently based on whether you invoked it as foo(4) or foo(2+2) or foo((int)16/4) because that information is gone by the time the function runs. It can tell what you passed, but it can't tell how you passed it.

For the same reason, a command can never behave differently based on whether or how you escaped its arguments. Quoting and escaping is a how, while the resulting string argument is the what.

Here is the equivalent execlp call of each of your attempts (echo is builtin in bash but behaves the same):

#    v-- How you passed it            v-- What you passed
echo -e     # execlp("echo", "echo", "-e", 0);   # prints nothing
echo '-e'   # execlp("echo", "echo", "-e", 0);   # prints nothing
echo "-e"   # execlp("echo", "echo", "-e", 0);   # prints nothing
echo \-e    # execlp("echo", "echo", "-e", 0);   # prints nothing
echo \\-e   # execlp("echo", "echo", "\\-e", 0); # prints \-e
echo '\-e'  # execlp("echo", "echo", "\\-e", 0); # prints \-e
echo "'-e'" # execlp("echo", "echo", "'-e'", 0); # prints '-e' (with quotes)
echo -- -e  # execlp("echo", "echo", "--", "-e", 0);   # prints -- -e

As you can see, the how doesn't affect output at all. It all comes down to the what. This is why all the escaping in the world will fail to have the intended effect.

Upvotes: 3

dawg
dawg

Reputation: 103774

Another way, using awk and a Bash C style string and a 'here string':

$ awk '1' <<< $'-e' 
-e

Works without quotes (if that is your goal):

$ awk '1' <<< -e
-e

Upvotes: 0

KamilCuk
KamilCuk

Reputation: 140960

How to echo the literal string "-e" (and nothing else) in bash?

printf '%s\n' '-e'
printf -- '-e\n'

From man echo -e is an option:

-e
enable interpretation of backslash escapes

From bash builtins:

echo ...
If the -e option is given, interpretation of the following backslash-escaped characters is enabled.
...
echo does not interpret -- to mean the end of options.

So echo -e will make echo interpret -e as a flag and print empty newline. To print -e you basically have to use printf (or you can use an implementation of echo that will allow to do that). I don't believe it is possible to print only -e with bash echo builtin.

printf is more portable. There are implementations of echo which do not take -e argument and it may work. On the net you can find various sites about echo portability issues.

Upvotes: 6

geckos
geckos

Reputation: 6279

 echo -e '\x2de'

Not very readable, but it works

Upvotes: 3

Related Questions