CODEWITHSUNDEEP
c++c++20std-span
user3624760
user3624760

Reputation:

Why does std::span lack size_type?

I've been updating old code that used my homebrew span class to the one that is more in line with C++20 std::span and I'm getting compile errors because std::span doesn't have size_type and instead has index_type. There's been a huge drama over whether index_type should be signed or not, but why skipping size_type? This breaks generic code that expects containers (or container-like objects) to have size_type.

Upvotes: 9

Views: 1021

Answers (2)

user3624760
user3624760

Reputation:

Everything Nevin said ...and it was fixed in Belfast.

Upvotes: 1

Nevin
Nevin

Reputation: 4863

The original proposal P1022R0, back when it was called array_view, had a size_type member. It was removed in the first revision P1022R1 as part of the simplification, as it wasn't needed because size() and element access were, at that time, using the signed index_type (aka ptrdiff_t). At the Kona 2019 meeting, that decision was changed in P1227R2 by changing index_type to be size_t.

Upvotes: 5

Related Questions