CODEWITHSUNDEEP
javaspringhibernatejpa
app
app

Reputation: 783

Hibernate doesn't alter the existing column is that a drawback?

I have a spring boot application that is connecting to PostgreSQL database. The DAO layer is implemented using Hibernate and JPA and auto-ddl is enabled so that hibernate takes care of creating table

Suddenly today my friend asked me to alter one of the column type BigInteger to String, then I said which is impossible because that column already filled with data and hibernate will not allow that

Now he is telling it is drawback in hibernate and we also had debate on does companies alter column definition based on requirement in production?

Question

  1. Is it really drawback in hibernate?
  2. Do IT companies or any organizations frequently alter column definition in production?

Upvotes: 2

Views: 1975

Answers (2)

Krzysztof Atłasik
Krzysztof Atłasik

Reputation: 22605

You should never use auto-ddl in production. It was never intended to be used in production, but for development. The reason why you shouldn't use it is that it might create un-optimal DDL or just damage your data.

The preferred approach to do changes in DB is to create a folder, which would contain all SQL scripts that alter the database structure and store it in version control. The common name is migrations. Then you could either manually run these scripts on your database or use tool like flyway (my recommendation) or liquibase.

So how can you make use of auto-ddl? For example, you could create a table for your new entity, then take DDL which was used to create it and after applying some adjustments (if necessary) store it in migrations. You can also use validate from hibernate.hbm2ddl.auto to check if your database matches with your entities.

And finally answering your questions:

  1. No, it's not a drawback of hibernate, because auto-ddl was never intended to do database migrations.
  2. Companies never change their databases using utilities like auto-ddl. Someone (DBA or developer) prepares migrations script and then it's applied either manually or by migration tool on release.

Upvotes: 9

StuPointerException
StuPointerException

Reputation: 7267

This is not a drawback of Hibernate, auto-ddl is designed to create the schema from the model and not update it. The reason is because, as you've found yourself, this is rarely straightforward and may require some "massaging" of the data.

I wouldn't say it's a common practise to change data types in production systems, but it's certainly a valid scenario to find oneself in. In my years I've had to do this a handful of times, although it's usually something as trivial as increasing the size of a varchar or changing from date to a datetime. Changing from a BigInteger to a String seems a little unusual and I would question how you've got to that position, it may indicate a problem with the design.

Either way, the solution is to change the data type in the database, which shouldn't be a problem, and then change the Hibernate mapping to reflect this change.

Upvotes: 2

Related Questions