CODEWITHSUNDEEP
assemblyclang
letrout
letrout

Reputation: 43

clang assembler error: ambiguous operand size for instruction

I'm trying build tinymembench with clang and am hitting errors on the assembly code. I can fix the easy ones (remove .func/.endfunc's) but the 'ambiguous operand size for instruction' errors on add and sub surpass my minimal assembly skills. I posted an issue on the repo but it's possible it's no longer being maintained.

Using this source file (removes the .func/.endfunc) I get errors like:

$ clang-8 x86-sse2.S /tmp/x86-sse2-dbaa71.s:86:9: error: ambiguous operand size for instruction 'add' add SRC, 64 ^~~ /tmp/x86-sse2-dbaa71.s:87:9: error: ambiguous operand size for instruction 'add' add DST, 64 ^~~ /tmp/x86-sse2-dbaa71.s:88:9: error: ambiguous operand size for instruction 'sub' sub SIZE, 64 ^~~~ ...

I looked at this answer which looks similar, but I wasn't able to translate it into an answer for these instructions.

Upvotes: 2

Views: 2964

Answers (1)

Peter Cordes
Peter Cordes

Reputation: 365277

I can fix the easy ones (remove .func/.endfunc's)

The .func macro includes a .set SRC, rsi which defines registers according to the appropriate calling convention (x86-64 System V, Windows x64, or 32-bit with stack args).

Removing it leaves just an undefined SRC symbol which of course is treated as a memory operand. (And add mem, imm doesn't have either operand implying an operand-size, so it's ambiguous.)

Your "fix" introduced this bug.

Use clang -no-integrated-as to use the system assembler instead of clang's built-in assembler. As expected, that builds https://github.com/letrout/tinymembench/blob/master/x86-sse2.S just fine on my Linux desktop with clang7.0.1. (And system assembler = GNU Binutils as 2.31.1)

Upvotes: 5

Related Questions