CODEWITHSUNDEEP
python-3.xoopsuper
Tedd8989
Tedd8989

Reputation: 72

Why can't super access the attribute in a class in python?

i have a question. In oops using python, super can access the method or constructor , but not the attributes . Why is that??

class Phone:

  def __init__(self, price, brand, camera):
    print ("Inside phone constructor")
    self.__price = price
    self.brand = brand
    self.camera = camera

def buy(self):
    print ("Buying a phone")

def return_phone(self):
    print ("Returning a phone")

class FeaturePhone(Phone):
    pass

class SmartPhone(Phone):
    def __init__(self, price, brand, camera, os, ram):
       super().__init__(price, brand, camera)
       self.os = os
      self.ram = ram
      print ("Inside smartphone constructor")

    def buy(self):
      print(super().camera) #Error
      print ("Buying a smartphone")

s=SmartPhone(20000, "Samsung", 12, "Android", 2)

print(s.buy()) #error
print(s.brand)

Can anyone please explain?? If possible then how?

Upvotes: 5

Views: 2002

Answers (2)

Clock Slave
Clock Slave

Reputation: 7977

You don't have to access the parent class to use one of its methods. Your class-SmartPhone inherits from the Phone class which allows you to access its attributes and methods using self. So you only need to call self.buy() to be able to use the method

class Phone:
  def __init__(self, price, brand, camera):
    print ("Inside phone constructor")
    self.__price = price
    self.brand = brand
    self.camera = camera
  def buy(self):
      print ("Buying a phone")
  def return_phone(self):
      print ("Returning a phone")

class FeaturePhone(Phone):
    pass

class SmartPhone(Phone):
    def __init__(self, price, brand, camera, os, ram):
      super().__init__(price, brand, camera)
      self.os = os
      self.ram = ram
      print ("Inside smartphone constructor")
    def buy(self):
      print(self.camera) 
      print ("Buying a smartphone")

s=SmartPhone(20000, "Samsung", 12, "Android", 2)

print(s.buy()) # this works
print(s.brand)

Upvotes: 0

Naoyuki Tai
Naoyuki Tai

Reputation: 443

First I thought - it's obvious. And, then, it is actually an interesting question, and I learned something new today.

super() doesn't return the instantiated class object. It returns an instance of "super" class that takes the class "SmartPhone" and "SmartPhone object" as arguments. It then runs this closure.

As such, you cannot get to the attributes of super class on the value of super() because it's an instance of "super" class.

https://docs.python.org/3.7/library/functions.html#super

Upvotes: 3

Related Questions