CODEWITHSUNDEEP
git
Aditya Verma
Aditya Verma

Reputation: 518

Can I switch branch without making commit?

okay so lets say I have two branches

1) new-branch

2) master

I have made some changes to new-branch but did not commit them yet, I want to switch to master now, but my workspace is not clean as I have made some changes since the last commit in new-branch. I don't wanna make a commit and I don't wanna carry those changes to master branch, I just wanna have a quick look at the master branch and come back to where I left in new-branch, Is it possible? If yes how to do it?

Upvotes: 2

Views: 3207

Answers (4)

torek
torek

Reputation: 488183

I recommend considering using git worktree add, at least if your Git is at least version 2.15. To do this, you might run this command from the top level of your work-tree:

git worktree add ../project.master master

which will create a whole separate work-tree in ../project.master. You can then look at your master branch in this separate work-tree, any time you like. You can even do work in master, if that's a thing you would normally do (many groups and organizations suggest not doing this at all though).

There are really two or three questions here, I think. In particular I think you've gone into an XY problem here: you are currently working in your new-branch, but you would like to view the files as seen in your master branch. So you then thought: I know how to view files and went from that to how can I save everything without making a commit? and have asked the question you asked, rather than the original, actual problem: How can I view the files I would have, if I checked out some other branch such as master?

The git stash answer is sort of the answer to the question you actually asked. See any of the answers by Noël Kra, customcommander, and/or Yusef Maali. That is, you can run git stash, which saves your as-yet unsaved work somewhere, then erases your as-yet unsaved work (which is actually saved now) and enables you to switch branches.

Technically, all git stash does is make some commits (usually two; sometimes three, if you ask for a third commit) that are not "on" any branch. So while that's sort of the answer to the question you asked, it also sort of isn't, because you asked Can I switch branch without making commit? and git stash makes commits.

Sometimes, you can switch branches without making a commit even when you have unsaved changes. That is, git switch master or git checkout master may actually just work. The drawback here is that it brings the uncommitted work along with the change in branches. It's also not clear to newbies to Git as to why Git behaves this way. For (much) more about that—eventually; don't look yet—see Checkout another branch when there are uncommitted changes on the current branch.

But you don't really need to switch branches. You really want to look at files in the snapshot at the tip of master. To get the entire set of such files, you can use git worktree. The git worktree sub-command, first introduced in Git 2.5, allows you to have multiple different git checkout-s at the same time, as long as each one is on a different branch and in a different working tree (directory / folder—use whichever term you like) in your file system.

If you only want to view one file from master, consider using:

git show master:path/to/file.ext

which will just display the contents of that file, as seen in the commit that is the tip of branch master. You only need a whole checkout, as in git worktree add, if you need to look at lots of files at the same time, in a fancy viewer for instance.

Upvotes: 1

Noël Kra
Noël Kra

Reputation: 40

To temporary save your changes use

git stash

To retrieve them again after switching back use

git stash pop

You can also apply the changes but keep the changes in your stash like follows:

git stash apply

With this command you could apply your changes on multiple branches.

Source: https://www.git-scm.com/docs/git-stash

Upvotes: 0

customcommander
customcommander

Reputation: 18901

Here's one possible workflow (YMMV)

You're in new-branch, made some changes but want to quickly go back to master

  1. Run git stash
  2. Run git checkout master
  3. Do whatever you need to do on master
  4. Go back to new-branch; run git checkout new-branch
  5. Reapply your changes; run git stash pop

While git stash is definitely something to consider, you should not be worry of making commits that you can trash away if you need to:

  1. On new-branch run git commit -a -m TMP
  2. Go back to master run git checkout master
  3. Do things on master then go back; run git checkout new-branch
  4. Either keep amending the temporary commit; run git commit -a --amend
  5. Or reset to the second to last; run git reset HEAD^

Upvotes: 5

Yusef Maali
Yusef Maali

Reputation: 2431

You need to use

git stash

Stashing takes the dirty state of your working directory – that is, your modified tracked files and staged changes – and saves it on a stack of unfinished changes that you can reapply at any time.

Take a look at the official documentation with examples:
https://git-scm.com/book/it/v2/Git-Tools-Stashing-and-Cleaning

A common workflow:

git checkout master

... do some work ...

git stash       <- save all the uncommitted works
git checkout new-branch

... do some work on new-branch ...

git commit      <- commit on new-branch
git checkout master
git stash pop   <- reapply all the changes you previously have on master

Upvotes: 3

Related Questions