Single flow: sign user in via Google oAuth AND grant offline/server access?

Question

I'm trying to implement Google sign-in and API access for a web app with a Node.js back end. Google's docs provide two options using a combo of platform.js client-side and google-auth-library server-side:

1. Google Sign-In with back-end auth, via which users can log into my app using their Google account. (auth2.signIn() on the client and verifyIdToken() on the server.)
2. Google Sign-in for server-side apps, via which I can authorize the server to connect to Google directly on behalf of my users. (auth2.grantOfflineAccess() on the client, which returns a code I can pass to getToken() on the server.)

I need both: I want to authenticate users via Google sign-in; and, I want to set up server auth so it can also work on behalf of the user.

I can't figure out how to do this with a single authentication flow. The closest I can get is to do the two in sequence: authenticate the user first with signIn(), and then (as needed), do a second pass via grantOfflineAccess(). This is problematic:

1. The user now has to go through two authentications back to back, which is awkward and makes it look like there's something broken with my app.
2. In order to avoid running afoul of popup blockers, I can't give them those two flows on top of each other; I have to do the first authentication, then supply a button to start the second authentication. This is super-awkward because now I have to explain why the first one wasn't enough.

Ideally there's some variant of signIn() that adds the offline access into the initial authentication flow and returns the code along with the usual tokens, but I'm not seeing anything. Help?

(Edit: Some advice I received elsewhere is to implement only flow #2, then use a secure cookie store some sort of user identifier that I check against the user account with each request. I can see that this would work functionally, but it basically means I'm rolling my own login system, which would seem to increase the chance I introduce bugs in a critical system.)

Answer 1

To add an API to an existing Google Sign-In integration the best option is to implement incremental authorization. For this, you need to use both google-auth-library and googleapis, so that users can have this workflow:

1. Authenticate with Google Sign-In.
2. Authorize your application to use their information to integrate it with a Google API. For instance, Google Calendar. 

For this, your client-side JavaScript for authentication might require some changes to request offline access:

$('#signinButton').click(function() {
   auth2.grantOfflineAccess().then(signInCallback);
 });

In the response, you will have a JSON object with an authorization code:

{"code":"4/yU4cQZTMnnMtetyFcIWNItG32eKxxxgXXX-Z4yyJJJo.4qHskT-UtugceFc0ZRONyF4z7U4UmAI"}

After this, you can use the one-time code to exchange it for an access token and refresh token. Here are some workflow details:

The code is your one-time code that your server can exchange for its own access token and refresh token. You can only obtain a refresh token after the user has been presented an authorization dialog requesting offline access. If you've specified the select-account prompt in the OfflineAccessOptions [...], you must store the refresh token that you retrieve for later use because subsequent exchanges will return null for the refresh token

Therefore, you should use google-auth-library to complete this workflow in the back-end. For this, you'll use the authentication code to get a refresh token. However, as this is an offline workflow, you also need to verify the integrity of the provided code as the documentation explains:

If you use Google Sign-In with an app or site that communicates with a backend server, you might need to identify the currently signed-in user on the server. To do so securely, after a user successfully signs in, send the user's ID token to your server using HTTPS. Then, on the server, verify the integrity of the ID token and use the user information contained in the token

The final function to get the refresh token that you should persist in your database might look like this:

const { OAuth2Client } = require('google-auth-library');

/**
* Create a new OAuth2Client, and go through the OAuth2 content
* workflow. Return the refresh token.
*/
function getRefreshToken(code, scope) {
  return new Promise((resolve, reject) => {
    // Create an oAuth client to authorize the API call. Secrets should be 
    // downloaded from the Google Developers Console.
    const oAuth2Client = new OAuth2Client(
      YOUR_CLIENT_ID,
      YOUR_CLIENT_SECRET,
      YOUR_REDIRECT_URL
    );

    // Generate the url that will be used for the consent dialog.
    await oAuth2Client.generateAuthUrl({
      access_type: 'offline',
      scope,
    });
    
    // Verify the integrity of the idToken through the authentication 
    // code and use the user information contained in the token
    const { tokens } = await client.getToken(code);
    const ticket = await client.verifyIdToken({
      idToken: tokens.id_token!,
      audience: keys.web.client_secret,
    });
    idInfo = ticket.getPayload();
    return tokens.refresh_token;
  })
}

At this point, we've refactored the authentication workflow to support Google APIs. However, you haven't asked the user to authorize it yet. Since you also need to grant offline access, you should request additional permissions through your client-side application. Keep in mind that you already need an active session.

const googleOauth = gapi.auth2.getAuthInstance();
const newScope = "https://www.googleapis.com/auth/calendar"

googleOauth = auth2.currentUser.get();
googleOauth.grantOfflineAccess({ scope: newScope }).then(
    function(success){
      console.log(JSON.stringify({ message: "success", value: success }));
    },
    function(fail){
      alert(JSON.stringify({message: "fail", value: fail}));
    });

You're done with the front-end changes and you're only missing one step. To create a Google API's client in the back-end with the googleapis library, you need to use the refresh token from the previous step.

For a complete workflow with a Node.js back-end, you might find my gist helpful.

Answer 2

While authentication (sign in), you need to add "offline" access type (by default online) , so you will get a refresh token which you can use to get access token later without further user consent/authentication. You don't need to grant offline later, but only during signing in by adding the offline access_type. I don't know about platform.js but used "passport" npm module . I have also used "googleapis" npm module/library, this is official by Google.

https://developers.google.com/identity/protocols/oauth2/web-server

https://github.com/googleapis/google-api-nodejs-client

Check this: https://github.com/googleapis/google-api-nodejs-client#generating-an-authentication-url

EDIT: You have a server side & you need to work on behalf of the user. You also want to use Google for signing in. You just need #2 Google Sign-in for server-side apps , why are you considering both #1 & #2 options.

I can think of #2 as the proper way based on your requirements. If you just want to signin, use basic scope such as email & profile (openid connect) to identify the user. And if you want user delegated permission (such as you want to automatically create an event in users calendar), just add the offline access_type during sign in. You can use only signing in for registered users & offline_access for new users.

Above is a single authentication flow.