Problem: Managing Multiple Roles for Users in a Fullstack Project

Question

I’m working on a fullstack project where I need to handle users with multiple roles. In my current setup, I have three main roles: client, recipient (destinataire), and administrator. The challenge I'm facing is that a user can potentially have more than one role at the same time. For example, a user might be both a client and a recipient, or even hold all three roles (client, recipient, and admin) simultaneously. Current Setup:

Database: I'm using Prisma ORM with a PostgreSQL database.
User model: Currently, my User model has a role field that is an enum with two possible values: CLIENT and ADMIN. Here's a simplified version of my User model:

model User {
  id          Int       @id @default(autoincrement())
  firstName   String
  lastName    String
  email       String    @unique
  phoneNumber String    @unique
  password    String?
  role        Role      @default(CLIENT)  // Role is an enum: CLIENT or ADMIN
  createdAt   DateTime  @default(now())
  updatedAt   DateTime  @updatedAt
}

enum Role {
  CLIENT
  ADMIN
}

The Problem: Single Role Limitation: Right now, I can only assign one role per user. However, I need to manage scenarios where a user can be both a client and a recipient (for example, someone sending a parcel and also receiving one), or they could also be an admin at the same time. Flexibility Needed: I need a system where users can hold multiple roles simultaneously, and I need a scalable solution as the system might involve new roles in the future.

Solution I'm Considering:

Many-to-Many Relationship: Instead of having a single role field in the User model, I'm considering creating a separate Role model and establishing a many-to-many relationship between User and Role. This would allow a user to have multiple roles (like CLIENT, ADMIN, and DESTINATAIRE).

Here’s a potential solution using Prisma:

model User {
  id          Int       @id @default(autoincrement())
  firstName   String
  lastName    String
  email       String    @unique
  phoneNumber String    @unique
  password    String?
  createdAt   DateTime  @default(now())
  updatedAt   DateTime  @updatedAt
  roles       Role[]    @relation("UserRoles")
}

model Role {
  id   Int    @id @default(autoincrement())
  type RoleType @db.VarChar(50) // Enum with values like CLIENT, ADMIN, DESTINATAIRE
  users User[] @relation("UserRoles")
}

model UserRole {
  userId  Int
  roleId  Int
  user   User   @relation(fields: [userId], references: [id])
  role   Role   @relation(fields: [roleId], references: [id])
  @@id([userId, roleId]) // Composite key for the many-to-many relationship
}

enum RoleType {
  CLIENT
  ADMIN
  DESTINATAIRE
}

Questions for the Forum:

Best Practice: Is this approach (using a many-to-many relationship between User and Role) the best way to handle multiple roles in a Prisma-based application? Are there any pitfalls or better alternatives?
Role Validation: How can I efficiently validate if a user has a specific combination of roles (e.g., both CLIENT and ADMIN) in the backend when handling requests?
Performance Considerations: Are there any performance considerations I should be aware of when using many-to-many relationships with roles, especially as the system scales?
Role Management: How can I handle role transitions smoothly? For example, if a user starts as a DESTINATAIRE (recipient) and later becomes a CLIENT, what's the best way to update their roles without breaking existing functionality (such as parcel tracking)?

Any insights, recommendations, or best practices would be greatly appreciated!

Problem: Managing Multiple Roles for Users in a Fullstack Project

Answers (1)

Related Questions