CODEWITHSUNDEEP
sqlpostgresqljoinrefactoring
shearn89
shearn89

Reputation: 897

SQL - JOIN on two result tables, ideas to refactor?

This may already have been asked, but StackOverflow is massive and trying to google for something specific enough to actually help is a nightmare!

I've ended up with a fairly large SQL query, and was wondering if SO could maybe point out easier methods for doing it that I might have missed.

I have a table called usage with the following structure:

host    | character varying(32)       | 
usage   | integer                     | 
logtime | timestamp without time zone | default now()

I want to get the usage value for both the MAX and MIN logtimes. After working through some of my old textbooks (been a while since I really used SQL properly), I've ended up with this JOIN:

SELECT *
FROM (SELECT u.host,u.usage AS min_val,r2.min
  FROM usage u
  JOIN (SELECT host,min(logtime) FROM usage GROUP BY host) r2
  ON u.host = r2.host AND u.logtime = r2.min) min_table
NATURAL JOIN (SELECT u.host,u.usage AS max_val,r1.max
  FROM usage u
  JOIN (SELECT host,max(logtime) FROM usage GROUP BY host) r1
  ON u.host = r1.host AND u.logtime = r1.max) max_table
;

This seems like a messy way to do it, as I'm basically running the same query twice, once with MAX and once with MIN. I can get both logtime columns in one query by doing SELECT usage,MAX(logtime),MIN(logtime) FROM ..., but I couldn't work out how to then show the usage values that correspond to the two different records.

Any ideas?

Upvotes: 2

Views: 185

Answers (1)

Erwin Brandstetter
Erwin Brandstetter

Reputation: 658562

With PostgreSQL 9.1 you have window functions at your disposal (8.4+):

SELECT DISTINCT
       u.host
      ,first_value(usage) OVER w AS first_usage
      ,last_value(usage) OVER w AS last_usage
FROM   usage u
WINDOW w AS (PARTITION BY host ORDER BY logtime, usage
             ROWS BETWEEN UNBOUNDED PRECEDING AND UNBOUNDED FOLLOWING)

I sort the partition by logtime and by usage in addition to break any ties and arrive at a stable result. Read about window functions in the manual.

For some more explanation and links you might want to refer to recent related answers here or here.

Upvotes: 3

Related Questions